This article covers 3.1.4 Research methods of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Laboratory Experiments: Control Bought at the Cost of Realism
- A laboratory experiment is run in a controlled setting.
- You manipulate the independent variable while holding other variables as steady as you can.
- The setting need not be a white-coat laboratory, only a place where you can keep tight control.
- The defining feature is a high level of control over the situation.
- That control is its greatest strength and the root of its main weakness.
Strengths and Weaknesses
Demand characteristics
Cues in a study that let participants guess its aim, so they change their behaviour instead of acting naturally.
- Strengths
- Extraneous variables are well controlled, so you can be more confident the IV caused any change.
- The standardised procedure makes the study easy to repeat and check.
- Weaknesses
- The setting can feel artificial, so behaviour may not match what people do in real life.
- People may pick up on demand characteristics and change how they behave.
- You test memory by having people learn a word list in a quiet cubicle with no clock and no phone.
- That gives you strong control over noise, distraction and timing.
- Yet learning a random word list is not much like remembering a shopping trip or a lesson.
Control Versus Realism
Ecological validity
How well the findings of a study apply to real, everyday settings rather than only to the artificial conditions of a laboratory.
- The tighter your control, the further the situation usually drifts from real life.
- The laboratory experiment deliberately picks control over ecological validity.
- That is a trade-off, not a flaw: it suits some questions far better than others.
- Do not say a lab experiment has no realism: say it trades some realism for more control.
- Do not label every indoor study a lab experiment, because it is the control that matters, not the room.
When to Use a Lab Experiment
- Reach for it when tight control of variables matters most.
- Reach for it when you need to replicate the study exactly to check the findings.
- Avoid it when capturing everyday, real-world behaviour is the whole point.
Field Experiments: Real Settings, Looser Control
Field experiment
An experiment carried out in a real-world setting rather than a laboratory, where the researcher still changes one variable but has less control over everything else.
- A field experiment is carried out in a natural, everyday setting.
- You still manipulate the independent variable yourself and still measure the dependent variable.
- The people are in a real situation, such as a bus, a high-street shop or a school corridor.
- It is still an experiment because you manipulate the IV.
- The one thing that sets it apart from a lab experiment is the natural setting.
Strengths and Weaknesses
- Strengths
- Behaviour is more lifelike, because it happens where it normally would.
- People often do not know they are being studied, so they act naturally and demand characteristics are reduced.
- Weaknesses
- Extraneous variables are far harder to control out in the real world.
- It is harder to repeat, and getting consent is tricky when people do not know they are taking part.
- On a busy Manchester bus, a researcher sends a helper to stand near seated passengers.
- On some journeys the helper carries a walking stick, on others nothing, and the team records how often someone offers a seat.
- The walking stick is the manipulated IV, but who happens to be on each bus is beyond anyone's control.
Field Versus Laboratory
- A field experiment has higher ecological validity but less control than a lab experiment.
- A lab experiment has tighter control but feels less like real life.
- The better choice comes down to whether the study needs realism or control more.
- Do not call a study a field experiment if nobody manipulated the IV.
- A natural setting on its own does not make a study a field experiment.
When to Use a Field Experiment
- Use it when realistic, everyday behaviour is what you most want to capture.
- Accept that you will lose some control over extraneous variables in return.
- Think hard about consent when people do not know they are being studied.
Natural Experiments: The IV You Find, Not Make
Natural experiment
An experiment in which the independent variable varies naturally and is not manipulated by the researcher, who simply records its effect on the dependent variable.
- In a natural experiment the independent variable varies on its own rather than being manipulated by you.
- You measure the effect of a change or difference you did not create.
- The IV is often a real-life event or an existing difference between people.
- You measure the independent variable, but you do not control it.
- It is used when manipulating the IV would be impossible or unethical.
Strengths and Weaknesses
- Strengths
- It lets you study variables you could never manipulate for practical or ethical reasons.
- Behaviour is realistic, because the difference or event is real.
- Weaknesses
- You have no control over the IV or over extraneous variables.
- The events or differences can be rare, so the study is hard to repeat.
- You want to know whether left-handers or right-handers are faster to react.
- You cannot hand someone a writing hand, so the IV, which hand they favour, varies naturally.
- You simply sort people into left-handed and right-handed groups and compare their reaction times.
Why Causal Claims Are Weaker
- Because you did not manipulate the IV, other differences between the groups could explain the results.
- You also cannot randomly allocate people to conditions, since the groups already exist.
- So you can suggest a link, but you cannot confidently say the IV caused the effect.
- Do not claim a natural experiment proves cause and effect.
- Do not describe the researcher as setting up the IV: here it varies on its own.
When to Use a Natural Experiment
- Use it when the IV cannot be manipulated for practical reasons.
- Use it when manipulating the IV would be unethical.
- Report the findings as a link, staying cautious about cause.
- What is a laboratory experiment, and give one strength and one weakness.
- What is a field experiment, and how does it compare with a lab experiment on control and realism?
- What is a natural experiment, and why can it not show cause and effect?
- Give one example of an IV that would have to be studied with a natural experiment.