Two groups of nine-year-olds attended science-club workshops about planning investigations.
In Workshop 1, pupils handled equipment and arranged cards showing possible steps. The tutor asked pupils to explain why each step was needed, gave feedback on their strategies and allowed them to revise their plans.
In Workshop 2, each pupil was labelled as a visualiser or verbaliser and received information only in the format matched to that label. The tutor praised successful pupils for having natural scientific talent.
Before and after the workshops, pupils completed different but equivalent versions of a seed-germination planning task. After the workshops, they also completed an unfamiliar investigation-planning task about insulation.
The mean scores were:
| Workshop | Seed-germination task before the workshop (out of 20) | Equivalent seed-germination task after the workshop (out of 20) | Unfamiliar insulation task after the workshop (out of 20) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 8 | 15 | 13 |
| 2 | 8 | 14 | 9 |
The club leader concluded, 'Both workshops worked equally well, so neither needs changing.'
Discuss whether the club leader's conclusion is justified and what changes, if any, should be made to the workshops. Refer to developmental psychology and the data in the table.
88 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.3 Development, covering 1.3.1 Early brain development, 1.3.2 Piaget's theory of cognitive development, 1.3.3 Piaget's four stages and education, 1.3.4 Egocentricity and conservation, 1.3.5 Conservation and egocentrism studies, 1.3.6 Dweck's Mindset Theory, 1.3.7 Learning styles, and 1.3.8 Willingham's learning theory. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.