An emergency-service training centre asks three equal groups of new volunteers to identify household objects in photographs of smoke-filled rooms. In the clear condition, the objects are fully visible. In both degraded conditions, the same types of object are blurred and partly hidden by smoke.
One degraded-photograph group is shown the correct object label after every response in the initial test. The other groups receive no feedback. The final test uses new photographs of the same types of object.
| Condition | Initial test accuracy (%) | Final test accuracy (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Clear photographs, no feedback | 90 | 91 |
| Degraded photographs, no feedback | 54 | 58 |
| Degraded photographs, labelled feedback | 56 | 77 |
Calculate the initial accuracy advantage for clear photographs over the mean initial accuracy of the two degraded-photograph groups. Calculate the change in accuracy in each condition and the feedback-related improvement after allowing for the change in the degraded-photograph group that received no feedback. Then evaluate the conclusion that the results prove perception is entirely top-down and that Gibson's direct theory is wrong.
80 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.2 Perception, covering 1.2.1 Sensation and perception, 1.2.2 Monocular depth cues, 1.2.3 Binocular depth cues, 1.2.4 Gibson's direct theory of perception, 1.2.5 Explanations for visual illusions, 1.2.6 Examples of visual illusions, 1.2.7 Gregory's constructivist theory of perception, 1.2.8 Factors affecting perception, and 1.2.9 Studies of perceptual set and motivation. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.