Systems and boundaries
Definition
System
The object or group of objects being studied, separated from its surroundings by a boundary.
Definition
Closed system
A system in which no energy is transferred into or out of the system, so its total energy stays constant.
- In physics, a system is the object or group of objects you choose to study, such as a falling ball and the Earth, or a kettle and the water inside it.
- Everything outside the system is called the surroundings, and the imaginary line that separates the two is the boundary of the system.
- Energy can cross the boundary in either direction, for example when a mug of hot tea transfers energy to the cooler air in the room.
- A closed system is one where no energy crosses the boundary, so no energy enters from the surroundings and none escapes to them.
- Very few single objects form a closed system on their own, because almost every object exchanges some energy with the air, the ground or whatever is supporting it.
- You can still make a system closed by drawing the boundary wide enough to include every object that the energy reaches, such as a ball, the Earth and the air around them.
- The whole Universe can be treated as the largest closed system, because there is nothing outside it for energy to be transferred to.
Conservation of energy
Definition
Law of conservation of energy
The law stating that energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transferred from one store to another.
- The law of conservation of energy states that energy cannot be created or destroyed.
- Energy can only be transferred, either from one energy store to another or from one place to another.
- For example, a moving object holds energy in its kinetic store, and an object raised above the ground holds energy in its gravitational potential energy store.
- Whenever a system changes, the energy in at least one store goes down while the energy in one or more other stores goes up.
- In a closed system the total decrease is always exactly equal to the total increase, because no energy has left the system and no new energy has appeared.
- This means there is no net change in the total energy of a closed system, however many transfers happen inside it.
- A net change is the overall change once every increase and every decrease has been added together, so a rise of 30 J30\ \text{J}30 J in one store and a fall of 30 J30\ \text{J}30 J in another give a net change of zero.
- Individual stores can change by large amounts, so conservation of energy never means that each separate store stays the same.
- It is the sum of all the stores in the closed system that stays constant from the start of a process to the end.
Example
A swinging pendulum
- A pendulum bob is pulled to one side and released, and the system is the bob, the string, the Earth and the surrounding air.
- At the highest point of the swing the bob is momentarily still, so its kinetic store is empty and its gravitational potential energy store is at its largest.
- As the bob swings down, its gravitational potential energy store decreases and its kinetic store increases by almost the same amount.
- At the lowest point the bob moves fastest, so its kinetic store is at its largest and its gravitational potential energy store is at its smallest.
- As the bob rises on the other side, energy moves back from the kinetic store to the gravitational potential energy store.
- Air resistance and friction at the pivot transfer a small amount of energy to the thermal stores of the air and the pivot on every swing, so each swing is slightly lower than the one before.
- The air and the pivot are inside the boundary, so the total energy of the system stays exactly the same from the first swing to the last.
Example
Keeping track of the totals
- A toy car rolls down a slope, and the system is the car, the slope, the Earth and the air.
- The gravitational potential energy store of the car decreases by 5.0 J5.0\ \text{J}5.0 J.
- The kinetic store of the car increases by 3.5 J3.5\ \text{J}3.5 J.
- Friction and air resistance increase the thermal stores of the car, the slope and the air by 1.2 J1.2\ \text{J}1.2 J.
- The rattling sound of the wheels carries 0.3 J0.3\ \text{J}0.3 J into the air, where it also ends up in a thermal store.
- The increases add up to exactly the decrease, so the net change in the total energy of the closed system is zero.
Choosing the boundary
- Whether a system counts as closed depends entirely on where you draw its boundary.
- If the boundary surrounds only a ball rolling across a carpet, the total energy of the ball falls as it slows down.
- This happens because friction and air resistance transfer energy out of the ball to the thermal stores of the carpet and the air.
- The ball on its own is therefore not a closed system, even though no energy has been destroyed.
- If the boundary is widened to include the carpet and the air, every joule that leaves the ball stays inside the system.
- The wider system is closed, so its total energy stays constant while the energy moves from the kinetic store of the ball to the thermal stores of its surroundings.
- In the end, much of the energy is spread thinly through the thermal stores of the surroundings, but every joule of it still exists.
- Always state the system you are describing, because the claim that total energy stays constant is only true for a closed system.
Common Mistake
- Do not say that energy is used up, lost or destroyed, because energy is only ever transferred between stores.
- Do not write heat energy or movement energy, because the correct names are the thermal store and the kinetic store.
- Do not claim that every store stays the same in a closed system, because only the total of all the stores stays constant.
- Do not apply conservation of energy to a single object that is clearly transferring energy to its surroundings, unless you have widened the boundary to include those surroundings.
Exam technique
Describing conservation of energy
- Start by naming the objects in the system, such as the ball, the Earth and the air, so it is clear which boundary you are using.
- Name the store that decreases and every store that increases, using the full store names.
- Link the changes to the law: the decrease in one store equals the total increase in the others, so there is no net change in the total energy.
- Use precise phrases such as no net change or the total energy stays the same, because vague phrases such as the energy balances out often fail to earn credit.
Self review
- What is meant by a system in physics?
- State what makes a system a closed system.
- State the law of conservation of energy.
- Explain what is meant by no net change in the total energy of a closed system.
- A ball rolling across a carpet slows down. Explain why the ball on its own is not a closed system.
- Explain why it is wrong to say that energy is used up.