Braking distance depends on speed
Definition
Braking distance
Braking distance is the distance a vehicle travels after the brakes are applied until it comes to a stop.
- Stopping distance has two parts. stopping distance=thinking distance+braking distance\text{stopping distance}=\text{thinking distance}+\text{braking distance}stopping distance=thinking distance+braking distance.
- Thinking distance is travelled before braking begins. For a fixed reaction time, d=vtd=vtd=vt, so thinking distance is directly proportional to initial speed.
- Braking distance is travelled while the brakes slow the vehicle. It depends on the vehicle's initial kinetic energy and the work done by the braking force.
Work done removes kinetic energy
Definition
Work done
Work done is the energy transferred when a force moves an object through a distance in the direction of the force.
- A moving vehicle initially stores kinetic energy. Ek=12mv2E_{\mathrm{k}}=\dfrac{1}{2}mv^{2}Ek=21mv2.
- The braking force does work against the motion. For a constant braking force, W=FdW=FdW=Fd, where ddd is the braking distance.
- Bringing the vehicle to rest transfers its initial kinetic energy. Therefore Fd=12mv2Fd=\dfrac{1}{2}mv^{2}Fd=21mv2.
- Rearranging gives the braking-distance model. d=mv22Fd=\dfrac{mv^{2}}{2F}d=2Fmv2.
- For constant mass and braking force, d∝v2d\propto v^{2}d∝v2. Doubling speed makes braking distance four times larger, while tripling speed makes it nine times larger.
- A larger mass increases braking distance for the same braking force. More kinetic energy must be transferred because EkE_{\mathrm{k}}Ek is directly proportional to mass.
- A smaller braking force increases braking distance. Worn brakes, wet or icy roads and reduced tyre grip limit the force available, so a greater distance is required to transfer the same energy.
Example
Comparing two braking distances
- Situation: a 1200 kg1200\ \text{kg}1200 kg car brakes with a constant force of 7200 N7200\ \text{N}7200 N.
- At 13 m s−113\ \text{m s}^{-1}13 m s−1: d=1200×1322×7200=14.1 md=\dfrac{1200\times13^{2}}{2\times7200}=14.1\ \text{m}d=2×72001200×132=14.1 m.
- At 26 m s−126\ \text{m s}^{-1}26 m s−1: d=1200×2622×7200=56.3 md=\dfrac{1200\times26^{2}}{2\times7200}=56.3\ \text{m}d=2×72001200×262=56.3 m.
- Comparison: the speed doubles and the braking distance becomes four times larger, as predicted by d∝v2d\propto v^{2}d∝v2.
Estimating stopping distance
- Convert speed to metres per second before calculating. A useful estimate is 30 mph≈13 m s−130\ \text{mph}\approx13\ \text{m s}^{-1}30 mph≈13 m s−1 and 60 mph≈27 m s−160\ \text{mph}\approx27\ \text{m s}^{-1}60 mph≈27 m s−1.
- Calculate thinking distance with d=vtd=vtd=vt. A typical alert reaction time may be estimated as about 0.7 s0.7\ \text{s}0.7 s when no value is provided.
- Calculate braking distance using energy or kinematics. Use Fd=12mv2Fd=\dfrac{1}{2}mv^{2}Fd=21mv2 when force is known, or use a valid constant-acceleration equation when deceleration is known.
- Add the two distances only at the end. Thinking distance and braking distance respond differently to increasing speed.
Exam technique
Showing the square relationship
- Start from Fd=12mv2Fd=\dfrac{1}{2}mv^{2}Fd=21mv2 and rearrange to d=mv22Fd=\dfrac{mv^{2}}{2F}d=2Fmv2.
- State which quantities are constant. The conclusion d∝v2d\propto v^{2}d∝v2 requires constant mass and braking force.
- Use a ratio when only a comparison is needed. d2d1=(v2v1)2\dfrac{d_{2}}{d_{1}}=\left(\dfrac{v_{2}}{v_{1}}\right)^{2}d1d2=(v1v2)2.
Common Mistake
- Do not state that total stopping distance is exactly proportional to v2v^{2}v2. Thinking distance is proportional to vvv, while only the braking part follows the square model under constant conditions.
- Do not use miles per hour in SI equations. Convert to m s−1\text{m s}^{-1}m s−1 first.
- Do not omit the factor 12\dfrac{1}{2}21 from kinetic energy.
- Do not assume braking force stays unchanged if road or brake conditions change.
Self review
- What two distances make up stopping distance?
- Why is thinking distance proportional to speed for a fixed reaction time?
- How can d∝v2d\propto v^{2}d∝v2 be derived from work done and kinetic energy?
- What happens to braking distance when speed doubles under constant conditions?
- Why can a wet road increase braking distance?