Skip to content

Course home

Sign up

13.2.5 Advantages of high-voltage transmission

Power wasted in transmission cables

Definition

Dissipation

Dissipation is the transfer of energy to the thermal store of the surroundings, where it becomes spread out and can no longer be used usefully.

Definition

National Grid

The National Grid is the nationwide network of cables, transformers and substations that transfers electrical power from power stations to consumers.

  1. Transmission cables are made of metal and therefore have resistance, so the current in them does work against that resistance and heats the cables and the surrounding air.
  2. The power dissipated in a cable is P=I2RP=I^{2}RP=I2R, where III is the current in the cable in amperes and RRR is the resistance of the cable in ohms.
  3. Because the current is squared in that expression, the wasted power is very sensitive to the current: halving the current cuts the waste to a quarter.
  4. The resistance of a cable increases with its length, so a long transmission route wastes more power than a short one carrying the same current.
  5. Thick cables of low-resistance metal such as aluminium keep RRR small, but the resistance can never be reduced to zero.
  6. Energy dissipated in this way heats the surroundings and is no longer available to the consumer, so it is paid for by the generator but delivered to nobody.

Raising the potential difference

  1. The power that must be delivered is fixed by what consumers are using, and it is linked to the transmission potential difference and current by P=VIP=VIP=VI.
  2. Rearranging that relationship gives I=PVI=\dfrac{P}{V}I=VP​, so transmitting the same power at a higher potential difference needs a smaller current.
  3. A smaller current in the cables means much less power is dissipated, because the loss depends on I2I^{2}I2 rather than on III.
  4. Raising the transmission potential difference by a factor of ten cuts the current to a tenth and cuts the wasted power to a hundredth of its previous value.
  5. A step-up transformer at the power station provides the high potential difference for transmission, and a step-down transformer near the consumer returns it to a safe level.
  6. The overall effect is that a far larger fraction of the generated energy arrives at the consumer, so the grid is much more efficient than it would be at a low potential difference.
  7. Transmitting at 230 V230\ \text{V}230 V over long distances would mean currents of thousands of amperes and losses larger than the power delivered, which is why the grid cannot work that way.
Example

Comparing losses at two potential differences

  • A power station delivers 20 MW20\ \text{MW}20 MW along cables whose total resistance is 5.0 Ω5.0\ \Omega5.0 Ω.
  • At a transmission potential difference of 20 kV20\ \text{kV}20 kV the current is I=PV=20×10620 000=1000 AI=\dfrac{P}{V}=\dfrac{20\times10^{6}}{20\,000}=1000\ \text{A}I=VP​=2000020×106​=1000 A.
  • The power dissipated in the cables is then P=I2R=10002×5.0=5.0×106 W=5.0 MWP=I^{2}R=1000^{2}\times5.0=5.0\times10^{6}\ \text{W}=5.0\ \text{MW}P=I2R=10002×5.0=5.0×106 W=5.0 MW.
  • At a transmission potential difference of 400 kV400\ \text{kV}400 kV the current is I=20×106400 000=50 AI=\dfrac{20\times10^{6}}{400\,000}=50\ \text{A}I=40000020×106​=50 A.
  • The power dissipated is now P=502×5.0=12 500 W=12.5 kWP=50^{2}\times5.0=12\,500\ \text{W}=12.5\ \text{kW}P=502×5.0=12500 W=12.5 kW.
  • Raising the potential difference by a factor of 202020 has cut the current by a factor of 202020 and the wasted power by a factor of 400400400.
  • The fraction of the generated power wasted falls from 5.020=25%\dfrac{5.0}{20}=25\%205.0​=25% to 0.012520=0.063%\dfrac{0.0125}{20}=0.063\%200.0125​=0.063%.

Working through the numbers

  1. Identify the fixed quantity first, which is almost always the power that has to be delivered.
  2. Find the current from I=PVI=\dfrac{P}{V}I=VP​ using the transmission potential difference, not the domestic one.
  3. Put that current into P=I2RP=I^{2}RP=I2R with the resistance of the whole route to find the power dissipated.
  4. Subtract the dissipated power from the transmitted power to find what reaches the consumer, and divide to find a percentage where one is asked for.
  5. Watch for prefixes, since a mixture of megawatts, kilovolts and ohms in one question is the commonest source of a wrong power of ten.
Example

Finding the fraction of power delivered

  • A cable of resistance 3.0 Ω3.0\ \Omega3.0 Ω carries 800 MW800\ \text{MW}800 MW at a potential difference of 400 kV400\ \text{kV}400 kV.
  • The current is I=800×106400 000=2000 AI=\dfrac{800\times10^{6}}{400\,000}=2000\ \text{A}I=400000800×106​=2000 A.
  • The power dissipated in the cable is P=I2R=20002×3.0=1.2×107 W=12 MWP=I^{2}R=2000^{2}\times3.0=1.2\times10^{7}\ \text{W}=12\ \text{MW}P=I2R=20002×3.0=1.2×107 W=12 MW.
  • The power reaching the consumer is 800−12=788 MW800-12=788\ \text{MW}800−12=788 MW.
  • The efficiency of the transmission is 788800×100=98.5%\dfrac{788}{800}\times100=98.5\%800788​×100=98.5%.
  • Doubling the transmission potential difference to 800 kV800\ \text{kV}800 kV would halve the current to 1000 A1000\ \text{A}1000 A and cut the loss to 3.0 MW3.0\ \text{MW}3.0 MW.

Costs and practical limits

  1. A smaller current allows thinner and lighter cables, so pylons can be spaced further apart and the network is cheaper to build.
  2. Cables that carry less current run cooler, so they expand and sag less and suffer less wear over time.
  3. A very high potential difference is dangerous, so cables are suspended high above the ground on insulators and the pylons carry warning signs.
  4. Very high potential differences need thicker insulation, taller pylons and larger, more expensive transformers, so the cost rises with the potential difference chosen.
  5. At extremely high potential differences some energy is also lost to the air around the cables, which sets a practical ceiling on how far the potential difference can usefully be raised.
  6. The potential difference used on each part of the grid is therefore a compromise between the energy saved and the cost and danger of the equipment needed.
Exam technique

Explaining high-voltage transmission

  • Build the answer as a chain: high potential difference, so small current for the same power, so small I2RI^{2}RI2R loss, so less energy wasted as heating.
  • Quote the relationship P=I2RP=I^{2}RP=I2R and say that the loss depends on the square of the current, because that squaring is where the marks are.
  • State that the power being transmitted is unchanged, since an answer that lets the power fall has missed the point of the question.
  • For a calculation, find the current before the loss, and show the two steps separately.
  • When a question asks for a drawback, name the danger of the high potential difference or the cost of the insulation and transformers rather than repeating the advantage.
Common Mistake
  • Do not write that a high potential difference reduces the loss directly, because it works by reducing the current.
  • Do not use P=V2RP=\dfrac{V^{2}}{R}P=RV2​ with the transmission potential difference to find the loss, since that potential difference is across the whole route and not across the resistance of the cable.
  • Do not confuse the potential difference across the cable resistance with the potential difference used for transmission.
  • Do not say that a transformer reduces the power, because a transformer changes the potential difference and the current while keeping the power the same.
  • Do not forget to square the current when using P=I2RP=I^{2}RP=I2R, since that single slip changes the answer by a factor of hundreds.
Self review
  • Explain why transmission cables become warm when they carry a current.
  • Explain why transmitting a fixed power at a higher potential difference wastes less energy.
  • Calculate the current in a cable delivering 50 MW50\ \text{MW}50 MW at 250 kV250\ \text{kV}250 kV.
  • Calculate the power dissipated in a cable of resistance 4.0 Ω4.0\ \Omega4.0 Ω carrying a current of 200 A200\ \text{A}200 A.
  • Give two drawbacks of transmitting electrical power at a very high potential difference.
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 13.2.5 Advantages of high-voltage transmission by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

13.2.5 Advantages of high-voltage transmission Revision Guide

  1. GCSE
  2. /Physics
  3. /13.2.5 Advantages of high-voltage transmission

Revision notes for Edexcel GCSE Physics 13.2.5 Advantages of high-voltage transmission: explanations and worked examples.

Revision guides