Scarcity forces every economy to choose
Definition
The basic economic problem: unlimited human wants set against limited economic resources.
Scarcity: the condition of not having enough resources to satisfy every want.
- Because the two never match, somebody must decide which wants are met and which go unmet.
- That need to choose is what makes economics a subject, since unlimited resources would need no choices at all.
- Every choice means giving up another, an idea called opportunity cost, covered in the next article.
Example
- The NHS has a fixed budget each year but an almost endless list of treatments it could fund.
- It cannot pay for every drug, nurse and hospital that patients might want.
- Limited resources force it to choose what to provide, which is the basic economic problem in action.
Scarcity is not the same as a shortage
Common Mistake
- A shortage is temporary: demand is greater than supply at the current price.
- Scarcity is permanent, because resources are always limited relative to unlimited wants.
Every decision maker faces the same problem
- Consumers choose what to buy with a limited income, so new trainers may mean going without a concert ticket.
- Workers choose how to use limited time and skills, such as taking a Saturday shift instead of a day off.
- Producers choose what to make with limited resources, so a car factory's line cannot build vans at the same time.
- Governments choose how to spend limited tax revenue, so more for the NHS can mean less for defence or schools.
Common Mistake
- Scarcity is the condition that resources are finite.
- The economic problem is the need to choose that scarcity creates.
- Neither ever goes away, because even the richest government cannot have everything at once.
Weigh the benefit against what you give up
- Every choice weighs an expected benefit against a cost, and that cost includes the next best alternative given up, not just the money paid.
- A choice is worth making only when the benefit is greater than what is sacrificed to get it.
- Whose benefits and whose costs are counted changes the answer, which is why decisions involve trade-offs between groups.
- Timing matters too, since a benefit that recurs every year can outweigh a cost paid only once.
Leeds City Council weighs a £5 million choice
- Leeds City Council has £5 million to spend and must choose between a new leisure centre and resurfacing its most damaged roads.
- The leisure centre would improve residents' health and bring in membership income.
- Choosing it leaves the roads damaged and raises the vehicle damage claims made against the council.
- The health and membership benefits recur every year while the claims are a one-off cost, so the council can reasonably build the centre even though drivers lose out in the short term.
- Change one fact, such as the roads being unsafe rather than merely bumpy, and the judgement flips, which is why the reasoning matters more than the answer.
Self review
- What is the basic economic problem?
- Why does scarcity force every decision maker to choose?
- What is the difference between scarcity and a shortage?
- When weighing up a choice, what two things should be compared?
- Why could Leeds City Council justify building the leisure centre?