Market failure sends resources to the wrong places
Definition
Market failure: the inability of the market system to allocate resources efficiently, so the quantity produced and consumed is not the quantity that is best for society.
- Prices are the signal that moves resources, because a high price pulls land, labour and capital into a market while a low price pushes them out again.
- Allocating efficiently means those resources finish up producing the goods that give society the greatest benefit from the scarce inputs available.
- The signal is built only from what buyers and sellers themselves pay and receive, so any effect on anybody else never reaches the price.
- The market therefore keeps trading and still clears, but it clears at a quantity that suits the two parties in the deal rather than the whole community.
Misallocation runs both ways: over and under-provision
Definition
Misallocation of resources: the outcome of that failure, where land, labour and capital end up producing too much of some goods and too little of others.
- Over-provision happens where part of the harm is left out of the price, so the good looks cheaper than it truly is and too many resources flow into making it.
- Sugary soft drinks were bought in volumes that left the NHS paying for the tooth decay and obesity treatment that the price of a can never covered.
- Driving in central London filled the roads, because the cost of a journey to the driver ignored the delay and the dirty air imposed on everyone else.
- Waste was sent to landfill cheaply while the lost land, the methane and the lorry traffic sat outside the gate price.
- Under-provision happens where part of the benefit spreads to people who do not pay, so buyers value the good at less than society does and too few resources flow into it.
- Vaccination is bought by individuals thinking about their own protection, although each person vaccinated also makes everyone around them less likely to catch the disease.
- Firms under-train their staff because a worker they train can carry that skill to a rival, so the economy ends up with fewer skilled workers than it needs.
- Home insulation is fitted less often than it would be if households counted the lower national energy demand alongside their own smaller bills.
Common Mistake
- Market failure does not mean the market has collapsed: it is still trading, just at the wrong quantity.
- Misallocation is not the same as scarcity: scarcity is unavoidable, misallocation is scarce resources put in the wrong place.
- Under-provision does not mean nobody buys the good, only that fewer buy it than society would want.
Cost 1: wasted resources and lower living standards
- Every resource used on an over-provided good is a resource not available for something society values more, which is the opportunity cost of the misallocation.
- Because the inputs are finite, that lost output is never recovered, so the economy produces a smaller bundle of what people actually want.
- Living standards fall as a result, since households end up with more of the goods that harm them and less of the housing, healthcare and skills that would raise their quality of life.
- Under-provision makes this worse, because goods such as vaccination and training would have made every other resource in the economy more productive.
Cost 2: third parties, then taxpayers, foot the bill
- Third parties who never bought or sold the good still pay for it, in dirty air, noise, congestion, illness or a polluted river.
- They receive none of the gain from the transaction, so the burden is placed on them without their agreement and without compensation.
- The bill is then often paid a second time by the taxpayer, because the NHS treats the illness, councils clear the litter and the Environment Agency cleans up the water.
- Goods people genuinely need are left under-provided at the same time, so scarce funding is spent treating damage instead of preventing it.
Case study
- Before charging began, road space in central London was free at the point of use, so a driver weighed only their own fuel, time and parking.
- The congestion charge from 2003 and the Ultra Low Emission Zone from 2019 put a price on entering the zone, and Transport for London reported both traffic levels and roadside nitrogen dioxide falling inside it.
- Two scarce resources, road space and clean air, had been over-allocated to driving precisely because nobody was charged for using them up.
- The clean-up costs had been landing on residents through worse health and on the NHS through treating it.
Identify misallocation by asking who pays and gains
- Ask who bears the cost, because if somebody outside the deal is paying, the price is too low and too many resources are flowing in.
- Ask who receives the benefit, because if people outside the deal gain for free, buyers undervalue the good and too few resources flow in.
- Ask what would change if everyone faced the full amount, since the quantity society wants is the one chosen when nothing is hidden from the price.
The size of that hidden gap is measured in 1.6.2a, and the methods a government uses to close it are covered in 1.6.1b.
Self review
- What does it mean to say a market allocates resources efficiently?
- Give one UK example of over-provision and one of under-provision.
- Why is lost output an opportunity cost rather than just an inconvenience?
- Name two costs of misallocation that fall outside the market transaction.
- Why does market failure not mean that the market has stopped working?