6.1.1 Extracting metals industrially and by electrolysis
Position relative to carbon decides the extraction method
Ore
A rock that contains enough of a metal or metal compound to make extracting the metal worthwhile.
Reactivity series
A list of metals in order of how readily they react, from the most reactive to the least reactive.
- Most metals are found in the Earth's crust as metal compounds, often oxides, mixed with rock.
- Extracting a metal means separating it from the other elements in its compound, most often from oxygen.
- A few very unreactive metals, such as gold and platinum, are found uncombined as the metal itself.
- In the reactivity series, carbon sits between aluminium and zinc.
- Metals less reactive than carbon, such as zinc, iron, tin, lead and copper, can be extracted by heating with carbon.
- Metals more reactive than carbon, such as potassium, sodium, calcium, magnesium and aluminium, must be extracted by electrolysis.
Carbon can take oxygen only from the oxide of a metal that is less reactive than carbon, so the metal's position relative to carbon sets the extraction method.
Metals below carbon are extracted by heating with carbon
Reduction
The loss of oxygen by a substance in a chemical reaction.
- When a metal oxide is heated strongly with carbon, the carbon removes the oxygen and leaves the metal:
metal oxide+carbon→metal+carbon dioxide\text{metal oxide} + \text{carbon} \rightarrow \text{metal} + \text{carbon dioxide}metal oxide+carbon→metal+carbon dioxide
- The metal oxide loses oxygen, so it is reduced, while the carbon gains oxygen, so it is oxidised.
- In a blast furnace, iron ore, coke and limestone are fed in at the top and hot air is blown in near the bottom.
- Coke is almost pure carbon, and it burns to heat the furnace and form carbon monoxide: 2C+O2→2CO2\text{C} + \text{O}_2 \rightarrow 2\text{CO}2C+O2→2CO
- Carbon monoxide reduces the iron(III) oxide in the ore to molten iron: Fe2O3+3CO→2Fe+3CO2\text{Fe}_2\text{O}_3 + 3\text{CO} \rightarrow 2\text{Fe} + 3\text{CO}_2Fe2O3+3CO→2Fe+3CO2
- Limestone removes sandy impurities by forming slag, which floats on the molten iron and is run off separately.
Do not say that the metal loses oxygen, because it is the metal oxide that loses oxygen and is reduced.
Copper, a non-ferrous metal, is extracted using carbon
Non-ferrous metal
Any metal other than iron, or an alloy that contains no iron, such as copper, aluminium or zinc.
- Copper is below carbon in the reactivity series, so its compounds can be reduced by carbon.
- The ore malachite contains copper carbonate, which breaks down on heating to give copper oxide:
CuCO3→CuO+CO2\text{CuCO}_3 \rightarrow \text{CuO} + \text{CO}_2CuCO3→CuO+CO2
- The copper oxide is then heated with carbon to give copper: 2CuO+C→2Cu+CO22\text{CuO} + \text{C} \rightarrow 2\text{Cu} + \text{CO}_22CuO+C→2Cu+CO2
- Copper made by heating its ore is impure, so it is purified by electrolysis before it is used for electrical wiring.
- Zinc and lead are other non-ferrous metals below carbon, and zinc can be extracted from zinc oxide in the same way: ZnO+C→Zn+CO\text{ZnO} + \text{C} \rightarrow \text{Zn} + \text{CO}ZnO+C→Zn+CO
Ores that contain very little copper can instead be processed by biological methods, which are covered in their own article.
Electrolysis extracts metals above carbon but needs more energy
Electrolysis
The breaking down of an ionic compound, when molten or in solution, by passing a direct electric current through it.
- Carbon cannot reduce the oxides of metals above carbon, because carbon is less reactive than these metals and cannot take the oxygen from them.
- These metals are extracted by passing an electric current through a molten compound of the metal.
- The compound must be molten so that its ions are free to move to the electrodes.
- In an aqueous solution, hydrogen would form at the cathode instead of the reactive metal.
- Sodium is extracted by electrolysis of molten sodium chloride, which gives sodium at the cathode and chlorine gas at the anode.
- Electrolysis needs a large amount of electrical energy, so it costs more than reduction with carbon and is used only when carbon cannot do the job.
- This is why aluminium smelters are often built near cheap electricity, such as the hydroelectric-powered smelter at Fort William in Scotland.
Do not say that chloride forms at the anode, because the chloride ions turn into chlorine molecules, Cl2\text{Cl}_2Cl2.
Aluminium is extracted by electrolysis in molten cryolite
- The ore bauxite is purified to give aluminium oxide, which is then dissolved in molten cryolite.
- Cryolite lowers the operating temperature from over 2000 ∘C2000\ ^{\circ}\text{C}2000 ∘C to about 950 ∘C950\ ^{\circ}\text{C}950 ∘C, which saves a large amount of energy.
- The cell has carbon electrodes, with the carbon lining of the steel tank acting as the cathode.
- Positive aluminium ions move to the cathode, where molten aluminium forms and collects at the bottom of the cell.
- Negative oxide ions move to the anode, where oxygen gas forms.
- The oxygen reacts with the hot carbon anodes to form carbon dioxide, so the anodes burn away and must be replaced regularly.
- The overall change is: 2Al2O3→4Al+3O22\text{Al}_2\text{O}_3 \rightarrow 4\text{Al} + 3\text{O}_22Al2O3→4Al+3O2
When a question asks you to explain how a metal is extracted, first compare the metal with carbon in the reactivity series, then name the method and give that comparison as the reason.
- Why can iron be extracted using carbon but aluminium cannot?
- Which substance reduces iron(III) oxide in a blast furnace?
- Which substance is oxidised when copper oxide is heated with carbon?
- Why must aluminium oxide be molten, rather than dissolved in water, during electrolysis?
- Why is cryolite used in the extraction of aluminium?
6.1.2 Life cycle assessment and recycling
Life-cycle assessments measure impact at every stage
Life-cycle assessment
An analysis of the environmental impact of a material or product at every stage of its life, from obtaining the raw materials to disposal.
- Obtaining raw materials covers mining ores, drilling for crude oil or felling trees, and the energy and land these use.
- Manufacture covers turning the raw materials into the product and its packaging.
- Use covers the energy and resources the product needs during its working life, such as the fuel a car burns.
- Disposal covers what happens at the end of the product's life, whether it goes to landfill, is burned or is recycled.
- Transport between the stages is also counted, because moving materials and products burns fuel.
At each stage, the assessment records the energy used, the resources consumed and the waste and pollution released.
A life-cycle assessment values each impact to compare products
- Some impacts can be measured as numbers, such as the energy used in megajoules or the mass of carbon dioxide released.
- Other impacts, such as the effect of a quarry on the landscape, are hard to measure and depend on value judgements.
- Different people weigh these effects differently, so two assessments of the same product can reach different conclusions.
- Products should be compared when they do the same job, such as one drinks container against another.
- An assessment may be selective, because a company could leave out stages that make its own product look worse.
- A shortened assessment used to advertise a product can therefore give a misleading picture.
Do not treat a life-cycle assessment as completely objective, because some impacts are estimated and the person carrying it out decides what to include.
Interpreting life-cycle data by comparing overall values
- Read every row of the table, including raw materials, energy, percentage recycled and cost, before deciding.
- Convert values given per kilogram into values per product, because containers made of different materials have different masses.
- Multiply the value per kilogram by the mass of one product in kilograms.
- A material with a lower energy use per kilogram can still need more energy per product if each product is heavier.
- One material is rarely best on every row, so weigh up the factors and state which one decides the choice.
Energy needed to make two containers
- Container A has a mass of 20 g20\,\text{g}20g and its material needs 60 MJ/kg60\,\text{MJ/kg}60MJ/kg to make, while container B has a mass of 40 g40\,\text{g}40g and needs 45 MJ/kg45\,\text{MJ/kg}45MJ/kg; which needs less energy per container?
- Convert the masses: 20 g=0.020 kg20\,\text{g} = 0.020\,\text{kg}20g=0.020kg and 40 g=0.040 kg40\,\text{g} = 0.040\,\text{kg}40g=0.040kg.
- Energy for A =0.020×60=1.2 MJ= 0.020 \times 60 = 1.2\,\text{MJ}=0.020×60=1.2MJ per container.
- Energy for B =0.040×45=1.8 MJ= 0.040 \times 45 = 1.8\,\text{MJ}=0.040×45=1.8MJ per container.
- Container A needs less energy per container, even though its material needs more energy per kilogram.
Recycling for a different use needs suitable properties
Recycling
Collecting and processing used materials so that they can be made into new products.
Viable
Workable in practice, because a process is technically possible, affordable and makes something people will use.
- Used PET bottles are collected, sorted by type of plastic, washed and shredded into flakes.
- The flakes are melted and pushed through tiny holes to make fibres, which are spun into yarn for fleece clothing.
- This works because PET keeps the properties a fibre needs, being strong, flexible and able to be melted and reshaped.
- A fleece does not need the food-grade purity of a drinks bottle, so small traces of contamination do not matter.
- Making fibres from recycled PET uses less energy and crude oil than making new PET, so the product can be cheaper.
- Crushed waste glass is reused in a similar way as a substitute for sand in road surfaces and concrete.
Old car tyres cannot be melted and reshaped, so they are shredded into rubber crumb for playground surfaces and sports pitches.
Recycling decisions weigh energy, cost, quality and demand
- Recycling conserves finite resources, such as metal ores and crude oil, and reduces the waste sent to landfill.
- Recycling aluminium uses only about 5% of the energy needed to extract new aluminium by electrolysis, so it is very worthwhile.
- Collecting, sorting and transporting waste also use energy and cost money, which can cancel out the savings for low-value materials.
- Mixed or dirty waste, such as plastic packets with food on them, is hard to separate, so contamination can make recycling uneconomic.
- Some materials lose quality each time they are recycled, as the fibres in paper get shorter, so they can be recycled only a few times.
- Recycling needs a market for the recycled material, since collected waste that nobody buys still ends up as waste.
When a question asks you to evaluate a recycling decision, give a benefit and a drawback linked to the data, then state which one outweighs the other for that material.
- Name the four main stages of a life-cycle assessment.
- Why can two life-cycle assessments of the same product reach different conclusions?
- Why should energy values given per kilogram be converted into values per product?
- Why is recycling PET bottles into fleece clothing viable?
- Give two factors that can make recycling a material uneconomic.
6.1.3 Biological methods of metal extraction
Biological methods make low-grade ores worth extracting
Low-grade ore
An ore that contains only a small percentage of metal, so extracting the metal by traditional methods is expensive.
- The richest copper ores have already been mined, so many remaining ores contain less than 1% copper.
- Smelting a low-grade ore means digging up, crushing and heating a huge mass of rock for a small mass of metal.
- This uses a great deal of energy and produces large amounts of waste rock and polluting gases such as sulfur dioxide.
- Biological methods use living organisms to concentrate the metal, so the ore does not need to be heated in a furnace.
- Mine waste and contaminated land that were once worthless can also be treated this way.
Biological methods trade speed for lower energy use, so they suit resources that are too poor to smelt.
Bioleaching uses bacteria to dissolve metal compounds
Bioleaching
A method of metal extraction in which bacteria convert metal compounds in an ore into a solution of metal ions.
Leachate
The solution of metal ions that drains out of the ore during bioleaching.
- Low-grade ore is piled in heaps and sprayed with dilute sulfuric acid, and bacteria in the heap get their energy by breaking down metal sulfides.
- This releases metal ions, which dissolve and drain from the bottom of the heap as the leachate.
- Copper is recovered from the leachate by displacement with scrap iron:
Fe+CuSO4→FeSO4+Cu\text{Fe} + \text{CuSO}_4 \rightarrow \text{FeSO}_4 + \text{Cu}Fe+CuSO4→FeSO4+Cu
- Iron is more reactive than copper, so it displaces copper from its salt solution.
- Copper can also be recovered from the leachate by electrolysis, which gives purer copper.
Bioleaching is used at copper mines in Chile, where huge heaps of low-grade ore are leached for months or years.
Phytoextraction uses plants to absorb metal ions from soil
Phytoextraction
A method of metal extraction in which plants absorb metal ions from soil and the metal is then recovered from the ash of the burned plants.
- Certain plants are grown on low-grade ore, mine waste or contaminated soil.
- Their roots absorb metal ions from the soil, and the plants store them in their stems and leaves.
- The plants are harvested and burned, leaving an ash that is rich in metal compounds.
- Burning the plants also releases energy that can be used to generate electricity.
- The metal is obtained from the ash by dissolving it in acid, then using displacement or electrolysis.
- Nickel has been extracted this way from plants such as alyssum, which store unusually large amounts of nickel.
Do not say that the plants make the metal, because they only take up metal ions that are already in the soil.
Biological methods save energy but produce metal slowly
- Both methods need far less energy than smelting, because the ore is never heated in a furnace.
- They release less carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide, and less waste rock has to be dug up and dumped.
- Phytoextraction can clean up land polluted by old mines while it collects the metal.
- Both methods are very slow, because bioleaching can take months or years and plants take a whole growing season.
- Bioleaching produces an acidic leachate containing toxic metal ions that must not escape into rivers or groundwater.
- Phytoextraction needs large areas of land and gives only a small mass of metal from each harvest.
When a question asks you to evaluate bioleaching or phytoextraction, compare it with smelting on energy, speed and pollution, then give a conclusion that depends on how much metal the ore contains.
- Why are biological methods used for low-grade ores?
- How do bacteria help to extract copper in bioleaching?
- How is copper recovered from the leachate?
- What happens to the plants in phytoextraction after they have absorbed metal ions?
- Give one advantage and one disadvantage of bioleaching compared with smelting.
6.1.4 The Haber process and the production of fertilisers
Crops need nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium compounds
Fertiliser
A substance added to soil to supply the mineral nutrients, mainly compounds of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, that plants need to grow.
- Plants take mineral ions from the soil through their roots, and harvesting a crop removes these nutrients from the field.
- Nitrogen compounds, taken up as nitrate or ammonium ions, are needed to make proteins for growth, especially of leaves.
- Phosphorus compounds, taken up as phosphate ions, are needed for healthy roots and for respiration.
- Potassium compounds are needed for healthy flowers and fruit and to help the plant resist disease.
- An NPK fertiliser contains compounds of all three elements, so it replaces the main nutrients a crop removes.
- The compounds must be soluble in water, because roots can absorb only dissolved ions.
Do not say that fertilisers supply nitrogen gas, because plants cannot use nitrogen from the air and take it in as dissolved nitrate or ammonium ions.
The Haber process makes ammonia for fertilisers
Haber process
The industrial process that makes ammonia by reacting nitrogen with hydrogen over an iron catalyst.
- Nitrogen makes up about 78% of the air, but it is very unreactive, so plants cannot use it directly.
- The Haber process combines nitrogen with hydrogen to make ammonia:
N2+3H2⇌2NH3\text{N}_2 + 3\text{H}_2 \rightleftharpoons 2\text{NH}_3N2+3H2⇌2NH3
- The reaction is reversible, so not all the gases react, and the ammonia is separated out while the unreacted gases are passed through again.
- It uses an iron catalyst at about 450 ∘C450\ ^{\circ}\text{C}450 ∘C and 200 atmospheres.
- Ammonia made this way is the starting point for almost all nitrogen fertilisers, such as ammonium nitrate and ammonium sulfate.
- Before the process began in the early 1900s, nitrogen fertilisers came from limited supplies such as manure and mined nitrates, so the Haber process allowed far more food to be grown.
The Haber process matters to farming because it turns the unlimited nitrogen in the air into compounds for fertilisers that increase crop yields.
Industrial fertiliser production uses several linked processes
- Air supplies the nitrogen, and natural gas and steam supply the hydrogen for the Haber process.
- Some ammonia is oxidised using air to make nitric acid, which then reacts with more ammonia to make ammonium nitrate: NH3+HNO3→NH4NO3\text{NH}_3 + \text{HNO}_3 \rightarrow \text{NH}_4\text{NO}_3NH3+HNO3→NH4NO3
- Sulfuric acid, made from sulfur, reacts with ammonia to make ammonium sulfate: 2NH3+H2SO4→(NH4)2SO42\text{NH}_3 + \text{H}_2\text{SO}_4 \rightarrow (\text{NH}_4)_2\text{SO}_42NH3+H2SO4→(NH4)2SO4
- Phosphate rock is mined and treated with nitric, sulfuric or phosphoric acid to make soluble phosphate compounds.
- Potassium compounds are mined, for example at Boulby in North Yorkshire, and need little processing before use.
- The products are blended in the right proportions to make NPK fertilisers for different crops.
- The plants on one site are often linked, so that the products and waste heat from one process feed the next.
An ammonium nitrate plant uses ammonia from the Haber process twice, once to make the nitric acid and once to react with it.
Making fertiliser salts in the laboratory by neutralisation
Neutralisation
A reaction between an acid and a base or alkali that forms a salt, and usually water.
- In the laboratory, ammonium sulfate is made by reacting ammonia solution with dilute sulfuric acid:
2NH3(aq)+H2SO4(aq)→(NH4)2SO4(aq)2\text{NH}_3\text{(aq)} + \text{H}_2\text{SO}_4\text{(aq)} \rightarrow (\text{NH}_4)_2\text{SO}_4\text{(aq)}2NH3(aq)+H2SO4(aq)→(NH4)2SO4(aq)
- Ammonia solution is an alkali, so this is a neutralisation reaction that forms a salt.
- A titration with an indicator finds the volume of acid that reacts completely with a measured volume of ammonia solution.
- The titration is repeated without indicator, using the same volumes, so the salt is not contaminated.
- The solution is partly evaporated and left to crystallise, giving crystals of ammonium sulfate.
- Aim: make crystals of the fertiliser ammonium sulfate from ammonia solution and sulfuric acid.
- Apparatus: a 50 cm350\,\text{cm}^350cm3 burette, a clamp and stand, a 25.0 cm325.0\,\text{cm}^325.0cm3 pipette with a pipette filler, a conical flask, a white tile, methyl orange indicator, dilute ammonia solution, dilute sulfuric acid, an evaporating basin, a Bunsen burner, a tripod and gauze, a filter funnel and filter paper.
Part 1: finding the volume of acid
- Pipette 25.0 cm325.0\,\text{cm}^325.0cm3 of ammonia solution into the conical flask and add a few drops of methyl orange.
- Stand the flask on the white tile and fill the burette with dilute sulfuric acid.
- Add acid from the burette, swirling, until the indicator turns from yellow to orange.
- Record the volume of acid used.
Part 2: making the crystals
- Pipette a fresh 25.0 cm325.0\,\text{cm}^325.0cm3 of ammonia solution into a clean flask, with no indicator.
- Add exactly the same volume of acid as before, so that the solution contains only the salt and water.
- Heat the solution in an evaporating basin until about a third of it is left.
- Leave the basin to cool so that the salt crystallises.
- Filter off the crystals and dry them between filter papers.
Accuracy and safety
- Leaving out the indicator in the second run stops it contaminating the salt.
- Do not boil the solution dry, because ammonium sulfate decomposes when heated strongly.
- Work in a well-ventilated room, because ammonia solution gives off an irritating gas.
- Wear eye protection, because the acid and the ammonia solution are irritants.
Comparing industrial and laboratory fertiliser production
Batch process
A manufacturing method that makes a fixed amount of product at a time, then stops before the next amount is made.
Continuous process
A manufacturing method that runs without stopping, with raw materials fed in and products removed all the time.
- The laboratory uses batch production, while industry uses a continuous process that runs for months without stopping.
- The laboratory starts from ready-made ammonia solution and sulfuric acid, while industry makes its ammonia and acids from air, natural gas, water and sulfur.
- A laboratory makes a few grams in glassware, while a factory makes thousands of tonnes in large steel reactors.
- The laboratory method needs several steps by hand, including titration, evaporation and crystallisation, which makes it slow.
- Industry uses automatic control and reuses heat from exothermic reactions, so its cost per tonne is far lower.
- Both methods make the same salt, because the neutralisation reaction at the heart of each is the same.
When a question asks you to compare industrial and laboratory production, pair up each point, such as batch against continuous, so every difference is stated for both methods.
- Why do farmers add fertilisers to fields that are harvested every year?
- What does each of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium do for a plant?
- Why is the Haber process important for agriculture?
- Which two substances react to make ammonium nitrate?
- Give two differences between the laboratory and industrial production of ammonium sulfate.
6.1.5 Alloys and their uses
Adding elements to a metal makes an alloy
Alloy
A mixture of a metal with one or more other elements, usually other metals or carbon.
- In a pure metal, the atoms are all the same size and sit in regular layers that slide over each other easily, so many pure metals are soft.
- In an alloy, atoms of a different size distort the layers, so the layers cannot slide as easily and the alloy is harder.
- Changing the composition of an alloy changes its properties, so the proportions are chosen to suit each use.
- Alloys can also be stronger, more resistant to corrosion or lower in melting point than the pure metal.
Do not call an alloy a compound, because its elements are mixed rather than chemically bonded in a fixed ratio.
Carbon content decides the properties of steel
- Steel is mainly iron mixed with a small percentage of carbon.
- Low-carbon steel, with about 0.1% to 0.3% carbon, is soft and easily shaped, so it is used for car bodies and food cans.
- High-carbon steel, with about 0.6% to 1.5% carbon, is much harder but more brittle, so it is used for cutting tools and chisels.
- Stainless steel is iron mixed with chromium and often nickel, and a common type contains about 18% chromium and 8% nickel.
- The chromium makes it very resistant to corrosion, so it is used for cutlery, saucepans and surgical instruments.
- A 250 g250\,\text{g}250g sample of steel contains 2.0 g2.0\,\text{g}2.0g of carbon; calculate the percentage of carbon and decide which type of steel it is.
- Percentage of carbon =2.0250×100=0.80%= \dfrac{2.0}{250} \times 100 = 0.80\%=2502.0×100=0.80%.
- A carbon content of 0.80%0.80\%0.80% lies in the high-carbon range, so the steel is hard and suits a cutting tool.
Copper alloys are harder than copper and resist corrosion
- Brass is copper mixed with zinc, often about 70% copper and 30% zinc.
- It is harder than copper, does not corrode easily and has a gold colour, so it is used for door handles, musical instruments and the pins of plugs.
- Bronze is copper mixed with tin, usually about 88% copper and 12% tin.
- It is hard, strong and resists corrosion even in sea water, so it is used for statues, bells and ship propellers.
- Cupronickel, copper mixed with nickel, is hard-wearing and silver-coloured, so it has been used for coins.
Pure copper is used for the wire inside a cable because it conducts better, but brass is used for the plug pins because they must be hard enough not to bend.
Uses of aluminium, tin and gold alloys
- Duralumin is aluminium with about 4% copper and small amounts of magnesium and manganese.
- It has a low density but is much stronger than pure aluminium, so it is used for aircraft bodies.
- Solder is mainly tin with small amounts of copper and silver, and it melts at a low temperature.
- This lets it melt and join electrical components without damaging them.
- Pure gold, called 24-carat gold, is too soft for jewellery, so it is mixed with copper or silver.
- 18-carat gold contains 18 parts of gold in every 24 parts of alloy, which is 75% gold.
- An 18-carat gold ring has a mass of 6.0 g6.0\,\text{g}6.0g; calculate the mass of gold it contains.
- Fraction of gold =1824=0.75= \dfrac{18}{24} = 0.75=2418=0.75.
- Mass of gold =0.75×6.0 g=4.5 g= 0.75 \times 6.0\,\text{g} = 4.5\,\text{g}=0.75×6.0g=4.5g.
- Why is an alloy usually harder than the pure metal it is made from?
- How does the carbon content of steel affect its properties?
- Which elements are mixed to make brass, and which to make bronze?
- Why is duralumin used for aircraft?
- What percentage of an 18-carat gold ring is gold?
6.1.6 Corrosion and its prevention
Corrosion is a metal reacting with its surroundings
Corrosion
The gradual destruction of a metal by chemical reactions with substances in its surroundings, such as oxygen and water.
- Most metals corrode by reacting with oxygen, often helped by water, to form metal oxides or other compounds.
- The metal gains oxygen, so it is oxidised.
- The more reactive a metal, the faster it tends to corrode, while gold and platinum hardly corrode at all.
- Aluminium is more reactive than iron but corrodes very little, because a thin layer of aluminium oxide forms on its surface and seals the metal underneath.
- Corrosion weakens metal structures, so bridges, cars and ships need regular protection and repair.
Only iron and steel rust, so zinc and aluminium corrode but do not rust.
Iron rusts only with both oxygen and water
Rusting
The corrosion of iron or steel by reaction with oxygen and water to form hydrated iron(III) oxide.
- Iron reacts with oxygen and water to form hydrated iron(III) oxide, which is rust: iron+oxygen+water→hydrated iron(III) oxide\text{iron} + \text{oxygen} + \text{water} \rightarrow \text{hydrated iron(III) oxide}iron+oxygen+water→hydrated iron(III) oxide
- Iron in dry air does not rust, and neither does iron in water that contains no dissolved oxygen.
- Salt water makes iron rust faster, which is why ships at sea and cars driven on gritted winter roads rust quickly.
- Acidic conditions, such as acid rain, also speed up rusting.
- Rust is weak and flakes off, exposing fresh iron underneath, so rusting carries on until the iron is used up.
Investigating the conditions for rusting
- Aim: show which conditions iron needs to rust.
- Apparatus: four test tubes in a rack, four clean iron nails, emery paper, tap water, boiled and cooled water, oil, anhydrous calcium chloride, salt, a bung and a label for each tube.
Method
- Clean four iron nails with emery paper and put one into each test tube.
- Tube 1: cover the nail with tap water and leave the tube open, so that both air and water reach it.
- Tube 2: cover the nail with boiled water and add a layer of oil, because boiling removes dissolved air and the oil stops more dissolving.
- Tube 3: add anhydrous calcium chloride and seal the tube with a bung, because calcium chloride absorbs water vapour from the air.
- Tube 4: cover the nail with salty water and leave the tube open.
- Leave the tubes for about a week, then compare the nails.
Accuracy and safety
- Clean every nail the same way, so that no nail starts with a layer of rust or grease.
- Only the nails in tubes 1 and 4 rust, which shows that both oxygen and water are needed.
- The nail in salty water rusts fastest, which shows that salt speeds up rusting.
- Wash your hands after handling calcium chloride, because it is an irritant.
A physical barrier stops oxygen and water reaching iron
- Paint protects large structures such as bridges, ships and car bodies.
- Oil or grease protects moving parts, such as bicycle chains, where paint would rub off.
- A plastic coating protects items such as garden furniture, fences and dish racks.
- Tin plating protects the steel of food cans, because tin is unreactive and not toxic.
- A barrier protects the iron only while it is unbroken, so a scratch lets oxygen and water reach the iron and rusting starts.
Do not assume that a tin coating protects scratched steel, because tin is less reactive than iron, so the exposed iron rusts even faster.
In sacrificial protection a more reactive metal corrodes instead
Sacrificial protection
Protecting iron from rusting by attaching a more reactive metal, which corrodes instead of the iron.
- A block of a metal more reactive than iron, such as zinc or magnesium, is attached to the iron or steel.
- The more reactive metal forms its positive ions more readily than iron, so it reacts with oxygen and water instead of the iron.
- The iron does not rust while the sacrificial metal remains, so the blocks are replaced once they have corroded away.
- Magnesium blocks protect underground steel pipes, and zinc blocks protect the steel hulls of ships.
- Sacrificial protection still works where the iron is exposed, which a barrier alone cannot do.
A ship's steel hull is painted as a barrier, and zinc blocks fixed to it give sacrificial protection wherever the paint is damaged.
Galvanising uses zinc as a barrier and sacrificial metal
Galvanising
Coating iron or steel with a layer of zinc to protect it from rusting.
- Galvanised steel is coated with a layer of zinc, usually by dipping it in molten zinc.
- While the coating is unbroken, the zinc acts as a physical barrier, keeping oxygen and water away from the steel.
- If the coating is scratched, the zinc still protects the steel by sacrificial protection, because zinc is more reactive than iron.
- The zinc corrodes instead of the iron, so the exposed steel does not rust.
- Galvanised steel is used for buckets, nails, fences and motorway crash barriers.
When a question asks why galvanised steel still resists rusting after it is scratched, say that zinc is more reactive than iron, so the zinc corrodes instead of the iron.
- Which two substances must be present for iron to rust?
- What is the chemical name for rust?
- Why does aluminium corrode very little even though it is more reactive than iron?
- How does a coat of paint prevent rusting?
- Why does a scratched galvanised bucket not rust?
6.1.7 Comparing and selecting materials
Ceramics, polymers, composites and metals have typical properties
Ceramic
A hard, brittle, non-metallic material made by heating substances such as clay or sand to a high temperature, including pottery, bricks and glass.
Composite material
A material made by combining two or more different materials, usually fibres or particles held in a matrix, with properties different from those of each material alone.
- Glass is a ceramic made by melting sand with other substances, and it is hard, transparent and brittle.
- Clay ceramics, such as bricks, tiles and china, are made by shaping wet clay and heating it in a kiln, and they are hard, brittle and strong when squashed.
- Polymers, such as poly(ethene), have low densities, are often flexible and are good electrical and thermal insulators.
- Composites combine two materials, with fibres or particles of one set in a matrix of the other, to get properties that neither has alone.
- Metals are strong, dense, malleable and good conductors of heat and electricity, but many corrode.
Each class of material has typical properties, but the values for particular materials within a class can differ widely.
Quantitative data show how much materials differ
Density
The mass of a material per unit volume, usually measured in kg/m³ or g/cm³.
Tensile strength
The largest pulling force per unit area that a material can withstand before it breaks.
- Density data show that steel, at about 7800 kg/m37800\,\text{kg/m}^37800kg/m3, is roughly eight times as dense as poly(ethene), at about 950 kg/m3950\,\text{kg/m}^3950kg/m3.
- A carbon-fibre composite can have a tensile strength of about 600 MPa600\,\text{MPa}600MPa, compared with about 400 MPa400\,\text{MPa}400MPa for steel and about 30 MPa30\,\text{MPa}30MPa for poly(ethene).
- Clay ceramics are strong when compressed but weak when stretched, with a tensile strength often below 10 MPa10\,\text{MPa}10MPa.
- Melting points range from about 110 ∘C110\ ^{\circ}\text{C}110 ∘C for poly(ethene) to about 1500 ∘C1500\ ^{\circ}\text{C}1500 ∘C for steel.
- Aluminium conducts heat about 200 times better than glass, which is why saucepans are made of metal but have polymer handles.
Mass of a steel and a composite car panel
- A car panel needs 0.0020 m30.0020\,\text{m}^30.0020m3 of material; compare the mass of a steel panel (density 7800 kg/m37800\,\text{kg/m}^37800kg/m3) with a carbon-fibre composite panel (density 1600 kg/m31600\,\text{kg/m}^31600kg/m3).
- Mass of steel panel =7800×0.0020=15.6 kg= 7800 \times 0.0020 = 15.6\,\text{kg}=7800×0.0020=15.6kg.
- Mass of composite panel =1600×0.0020=3.2 kg= 1600 \times 0.0020 = 3.2\,\text{kg}=1600×0.0020=3.2kg.
- Divide the masses: 15.63.2=4.9\dfrac{15.6}{3.2} = 4.93.215.6=4.9, so the steel panel has about five times the mass of the composite panel.
Choosing a material by matching properties to use
Brittle
Likely to crack or shatter when hit or bent, rather than changing shape.
- List the properties the use needs, such as strength, density, heat resistance or resistance to corrosion.
- Then find the material whose values meet every requirement, not the one that is best at only one of them.
- Window glass is chosen because it is transparent and hard to scratch, even though it is brittle.
- Bricks suit walls because a wall pushes down on them, and clay ceramics are strong when compressed.
- Poly(ethene) suits carrier bags and bottles because it has a low density, is flexible and does not react with water.
- Steel suits bridges and building frames because it has a high tensile strength, even though it is dense and needs protecting from rust.
Do not describe a polymer as light, because the property to quote is its low density.
Composites combine materials to offset each other's weaknesses
- Reinforced concrete sets steel rods inside concrete, because concrete is strong when compressed and steel is strong when stretched.
- Fibreglass sets glass fibres in a polymer resin, giving a strong, low-density material for boat hulls and canoes.
- Carbon-fibre composite sets carbon fibres in a polymer resin, giving very high strength with low density for racing bikes and aircraft parts.
- Composites are often expensive to make and hard to recycle, because their materials cannot easily be separated.
- Wood is a natural composite of cellulose fibres held in a matrix of lignin.
When a question gives a table and asks you to select a material, quote the values that meet each requirement and reject every other material with the value that rules it out.
- Roughly how many times denser is steel than poly(ethene)?
- Why are bricks suitable for walls but not for parts that are stretched?
- Why are saucepan handles often made of a polymer?
- Why is reinforced concrete stronger than concrete alone?
- Why might carbon-fibre composite be chosen instead of steel for a racing bike frame?
6.1.8 Industrial conditions, rate and position of equilibrium
Yield and rate often need different conditions
Position of equilibrium
The relative amounts of reactants and products in a reaction mixture at equilibrium.
Compromise conditions
Reaction conditions chosen to give an acceptable yield at an acceptable rate and cost, rather than the best possible value of any one of them.
- In a reversible reaction, the position of equilibrium decides how much product is present once equilibrium is reached.
- The rate of reaction decides how quickly the product forms and how soon equilibrium is reached.
- A change in conditions can improve one while making the other worse, so industry chooses compromise conditions.
- A company wants the most product per hour at the lowest cost, rather than the highest possible yield.
- A high yield reached very slowly gives less product each day than a lower yield reached quickly.
- The same trade-off applies to making ethanol from ethene and steam, an exothermic reversible reaction run at about 300 ∘C300\ ^{\circ}\text{C}300 ∘C and 60 to 70 atmospheres with a phosphoric acid catalyst.
Do not explain a higher yield by saying there are more collisions, because collisions explain rate, while yield depends on the position of equilibrium.
Low temperature favours ammonia but slows the reaction
Catalyst
A substance that increases the rate of a reaction by providing an alternative pathway with a lower activation energy without being used up.
- The forward reaction is exothermic: N2(g)+3H2(g)⇌2NH3(g)\text{N}_2\text{(g)} + 3\text{H}_2\text{(g)} \rightleftharpoons 2\text{NH}_3\text{(g)}N2(g)+3H2(g)⇌2NH3(g)
- Lowering the temperature shifts the position of equilibrium to the right, towards the exothermic direction, so the yield of ammonia increases.
- At 200 atmospheres, the equilibrium yield is about 36% at 400 ∘C400\ ^{\circ}\text{C}400 ∘C but only about 18% at 500 ∘C500\ ^{\circ}\text{C}500 ∘C.
- At a low temperature, fewer particles have energy greater than the activation energy, so the rate is too slow to be economical.
- About 450 ∘C450\ ^{\circ}\text{C}450 ∘C is used as a compromise, giving a lower yield but a much faster rate.
- The iron catalyst also works well only at a high temperature, which is another reason the temperature cannot be low.
The catalyst speeds up the forward and reverse reactions equally, so equilibrium is reached sooner but the yield does not change.
High pressure raises Haber yield, rate and costs
- There are four moles of gas on the left of the equation and two on the right, so a higher pressure shifts the position of equilibrium towards ammonia.
- At 400 ∘C400\ ^{\circ}\text{C}400 ∘C, the equilibrium yield rises from about 25% at 100 atmospheres to about 47% at 300 atmospheres.
- A higher pressure also increases the rate, because the gas particles are closer together and collide more often.
- Very high pressures need thick-walled equipment and a lot of energy to compress the gases, which is expensive and increases the risk of leaks.
- About 200 atmospheres is used as a compromise between a good yield and the cost of equipment and energy.
Raising the pressure improves both the yield and the rate, so its limit is set by cost and safety rather than by the chemistry.
Graphs show how conditions affect the rate
- On a graph of rate against temperature, the rate rises more and more steeply as the temperature increases.
- On a graph of rate against pressure for a reaction of gases, the rate rises as the pressure increases, because the gases become more concentrated.
- Read values from the graph at the conditions being compared, and describe the change using numbers from the axes.
- A rate graph shows only how fast the reaction goes, so it must be read alongside yield data before conditions are chosen.
- The best temperature is where the rate is high enough while the yield has not fallen too far.
Choosing a temperature for making ammonia
- A graph shows a rate of ammonia production of 222 units at 350 ∘C350\ ^{\circ}\text{C}350 ∘C and 101010 units at 450 ∘C450\ ^{\circ}\text{C}450 ∘C, while the equilibrium yield falls from about 50% to about 28%; explain why 450 ∘C450\ ^{\circ}\text{C}450 ∘C is chosen.
- The rate increases by a factor of 102=5\dfrac{10}{2} = 5210=5 between 350 ∘C350\ ^{\circ}\text{C}350 ∘C and 450 ∘C450\ ^{\circ}\text{C}450 ∘C.
- The yield falls from about 50% to about 28%, so it is a little over half as large.
- Five times the rate more than makes up for a yield about half as large, so more ammonia is made each hour at 450 ∘C450\ ^{\circ}\text{C}450 ∘C.
Raw material and energy costs affect commercial conditions
- Nitrogen comes cheaply from the air, but hydrogen is made from natural gas, so the price of gas has a large effect on the cost of ammonia.
- Only about 15% of the gases react on each pass through the reactor, so the unreacted nitrogen and hydrogen are recycled and no raw material is wasted.
- Ammonia is removed by cooling the mixture, because ammonia condenses at a much higher temperature than nitrogen and hydrogen.
- Heating and compressing the gases uses a lot of energy, so a lower temperature and pressure save fuel and electricity.
- The heat released by the exothermic reaction is used to preheat the incoming gases, which cuts energy costs.
- The catalyst gives an acceptable rate at a lower temperature than would otherwise be needed, which saves energy.
When a question asks you to explain the conditions used in an industrial process, deal with each condition in turn and say what it does to the rate, to the yield and to the cost.
- Why does a low temperature increase the equilibrium yield of ammonia?
- Why is a low temperature not used in the Haber process?
- Why does a higher pressure increase the yield of ammonia?
- Why is a pressure much higher than 200 atmospheres not used?
- How does recycling the unreacted gases reduce the cost of making ammonia?