What a stakeholder objective is
Stakeholder objective
What a particular stakeholder group wants to get out of the business.
- Each group judges the business against its own objective, which follows from the way that group is linked to the firm: owners have money in it, employees draw pay from it, suppliers sell to it, customers buy from it and residents live next to it.
- Objectives are not all financial, so the residents near a Tesco distribution centre are judging the number of lorries on their road rather than the size of the profit.
What owners and shareholders want
Dividend
The part of a company's profit after tax that is paid out to shareholders rather than retained.
- High dividend payments: shareholders want as large a share of the profit paid out to them as possible, because the dividend is the cash return on the money they risked.
- Dividends can only be paid out of profit, so this objective makes shareholders push for higher revenue and tighter control of costs such as wages.
- A rising value for their stake: a shareholder in Barclays also gains if the share price rises, so growth in the business matters as well as this year's payout.
- Profit as income: a sole trader takes the profit directly rather than as a dividend, so for the owner of a single barber's shop the profit is the household income.
- If a plc makes £800,000 profit and pays £300,000 of it out as dividends, the shareholders receive that £300,000 and the remaining £500,000 stays in the business.
- Shareholders who want a high dividend and directors who want to reinvest are both looking at the same £800,000.
What employees want
- Maximising pay: workers want the highest wage or salary they can get, because that pay is what covers their rent, bills and food.
- Pay is a cost to the business and an income to the worker, which is why the same wage rise is read in opposite ways by the two groups.
- Job security: employees want to know the job will still exist next year, so a permanent contract at the Nissan plant in Sunderland is worth more to a worker than a short-term one at the same rate.
- Good working conditions: this covers safe equipment, reasonable hours, proper breaks and being treated fairly by managers, and it is why warehouse staff care about targets as well as pay.
- A Deliveroo rider paid per delivery has all three objectives at once: a higher rate per drop, enough guaranteed work to rely on, and safe conditions on the road.
- Meeting one of the three does not satisfy the other two.
What customers and suppliers want
- Customers want quality and value for money: they want the product to work, to last and to be safe, at the lowest price they can find it, which is why Aldi shoppers compare a basket of branded goods against the same basket at Tesco.
- Customers also want choice and good service: a wide range, quick delivery, easy returns and staff who can answer a question all count, so a Currys customer judges the after-sales help as well as the price of the machine.
- Suppliers want prompt payment: being paid within the agreed period, rather than being made to wait 90 days, is often a supplier's first objective.
- Late payment starves the supplier's cash flow, because it still has to pay its own staff and materials while it waits.
- Suppliers want regular repeat orders at a fair price: a steady contract lets a small bakery plan its own production and staffing, so it will accept a lower price per unit for a long-term order.
- Do not write that every stakeholder wants the business to make more profit, because employees are judging their payslip and residents are judging the lorries on their road.
- Match the objective to the exact group named, since a supplier's aim of being paid on time is nothing like a customer's aim of paying a low price.
What the local community wants
- Jobs for local people: a community wants the business to recruit nearby, because local wages are then spent in nearby shops and the area's unemployment falls.
- Minimising environmental impact: residents want as little pollution, noise, litter and waste as possible, so a community near a JCB factory cares about emissions from the site and what happens to its scrap.
- Traffic is part of this objective, since lorries arriving before six in the morning bring noise and congestion to streets that were quiet before.
- A business that supports the area: communities want firms to use local suppliers, sponsor local teams and keep buildings and car parks in good order rather than leaving an eyesore.
When a large depot opens on the edge of a town, the community's two objectives point in different directions: several hundred jobs is what it wanted, and several hundred lorry movements a day is not.
This article covers what each group wants; what happens when those wants pull against each other is stakeholder conflict, covered in the article on the impact and influence of stakeholders.
- Use the objective the case actually raises, so if the text says staff have had no pay rise for two years, write about maximising pay rather than working conditions.
- The mistake to avoid is giving the business's own aims, such as survival, growth or market share, when the question asked what a stakeholder wants.
- What is a stakeholder objective?
- What is a dividend, and which stakeholder group wants it to be high?
- Give three objectives of employees.
- What two things does a supplier most want from a business it sells to?
- Name two things the local community wants a nearby business to keep low.