Skip to content

Course home

1.1 Proof by Contradiction

1.1 Proof by Contradiction

EasyMediumHard
1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556575859606162636465666768697071727374757677787980818283848586878889909192
Question 41
a.

A technician monitoring a high-precision chemical reaction states that the temperature, TTT in ∘C^\circ C∘C, must satisfy the constraint 54.4<T<54.554.4 < T < 54.554.4<T<54.5. The technician claims that 54.554.554.5 is the largest possible temperature within this specification.

Explain the error in the technician's statement.

[1]
bi.

A research scientist argues that there is no largest value for TTT in the interval 54.4<T<54.554.4 < T < 54.554.4<T<54.5 and provides the following proof by contradiction:

Step 1: Assume there is a largest temperature in the interval 54.4<T<54.554.4 < T < 54.554.4<T<54.5 and let this largest value be LLL.

Step 2: Let k=L+54.52k = \frac{L + 54.5}{2}k=2L+54.5​.

Step 3: L<k<54.5L < k < 54.5L<k<54.5, which is a contradiction.

Step 4: Therefore, there is no largest temperature in the interval 54.4<T<54.554.4 < T < 54.554.4<T<54.5.

Explain the contradiction stated in Step 3.

[1]
bii.

Using a similar method, prove that there is no smallest value of TTT in the interval 54.4<T<54.554.4 < T < 54.554.4<T<54.5.

[3]
Markscheme

1.1 Proof by Contradiction Questions

  1. A Level
  2. /Maths
  3. /1.1 Proof by Contradiction

107 exam-style questions on Edexcel A Level Maths 1.1 Proof by Contradiction. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.

Question bank