2.1.1a Measures and comparisons of growth
Real vs nominal GDP
Economic growth: the percentage change in real GDP over a period of time.
Real GDP: the value of output measured at constant base-year prices, so the effect of inflation is stripped out.
Nominal GDP: the value of output measured at current prices.
- Nominal GDP can rise even when output is unchanged, simply because prices have risen, so it overstates genuine growth.
- Real growth is therefore approximately nominal growth minus the rate of inflation:
- Nominal GDP is like the running total on a shopping receipt, which climbs when prices rise even if you buy the same goods.
- Real GDP is like counting the actual items in the basket, showing whether output has genuinely grown.
Value, volume and per capita
Value: a money total of output; volume: the physical quantity of output produced.
Total: output for the whole economy; per capita: output divided by the population.
- GDP per capita is the better guide to living standards because it adjusts for the size of the population, so fast population growth can leave people no better off even when total GDP is rising.
- Real GDP rises from £2,000bn to £2,060bn in a country of 50 million people.
- So output per person is about £41,200 a year, the figure that matters for living standards.
GDP and GNI
GDP: the value of output produced within a country's borders.
Gross National Income (GNI): the income earned by a country's residents, including net income from abroad.
- The two diverge when large net income flows cross borders, such as profits sent home by foreign firms; in Ireland, heavy multinational activity makes GNI markedly lower than GDP.
International comparisons
Purchasing power parities (PPPs): exchange rates that equalise the cost of a common basket of goods, adjusting for differences in the cost of living that market exchange rates ignore.
- To compare growth across countries and over time the figures must be made comparable: real, per capita and expressed in a common currency.
- The same income buys more where local prices are low, so PPP-adjusted figures give a fairer comparison of living standards than market exchange rates; India, for instance, is around the fifth-largest economy at market exchange rates but the third-largest once output is measured at PPP.
- Comparisons remain imperfect because data reliability, the size of the informal economy and income distribution differ between countries.
- State economic growth as the percentage change in real, not nominal, GDP.
- Use GDP per capita and PPP-adjusted figures when comparing living standards across countries.
- Do not compare nominal GDP across years, because that overstates real growth.
- Do not compare GDP between countries at market exchange rates without adjusting for purchasing power parity.
- How is economic growth measured?
- What is the difference between real and nominal GDP?
- How does GNI differ from GDP?
- Why are PPP-adjusted figures used in international comparisons?
- What is the difference between value and volume?
2.1.1b Limitations of GDP and national happiness
What GDP omits
Welfare: the overall wellbeing and quality of life of a population, which output alone does not capture.
Hidden economy: unrecorded activity, such as cash-in-hand and illegal work, that is excluded from official GDP.
- A rise in GDP does not always mean a rise in living standards, because output and welfare are not the same thing.
- GDP omits unpaid household work and output in the hidden economy, so it understates true activity.
- It ignores how income is distributed, so an average can hide wide inequality.
- It takes no account of negative externalities such as pollution, nor of the value of leisure time.
- China's real GDP grew by roughly 10% a year through the 2000s, yet air pollution in cities such as Beijing worsened sharply and income inequality widened at the same time.
- The headline growth figure then overstates the true improvement in welfare, because those environmental and distributional costs are left out of GDP.
Comparing living standards
- Comparisons over time must use real GDP per capita to strip out inflation and population change.
- Comparisons between countries must adjust for purchasing power parity and still face differences in data reliability and in what is counted.
- Public services, working hours and the size of the informal economy vary, so like-for-like comparison is difficult.
- Comparing GDP across countries is like comparing exam scores set by different marking schemes.
- The raw numbers must first be converted to a common basis, which is what PPP adjustment does.
National wellbeing
National wellbeing: how satisfied people feel with their lives, measured alongside GDP to capture welfare that output misses.
- In the UK the ONS surveys life satisfaction, sense of worth, happiness and anxiety alongside GDP.
- Higher real incomes tend to raise happiness, but only up to a point; beyond a threshold, further rises add little to measured subjective happiness (the Easterlin paradox).
- So GDP per capita is a useful guide to material output but an incomplete measure of welfare.
Does higher GDP mean higher living standards?
- It holds because higher real GDP per capita usually funds more goods, better public services and rising life expectancy, and across countries richer populations tend to report greater life satisfaction.
- But GDP ignores distribution, pollution, non-market work and leisure, so growth concentrated among the richest or driven by environmental damage can raise the headline figure without improving most people's lives.
- But beyond a threshold of income the link to subjective happiness weakens, so extra output adds little welfare in an already-rich economy like the UK.
- On balance, whether higher GDP means higher living standards depends on how the gains are distributed, what they cost the environment, and the income level the country starts from.
- List clearly what GDP omits: distribution, externalities, non-market work and leisure.
- Bring in national wellbeing and the income-happiness relationship alongside GDP.
- Do not treat higher GDP per capita as automatically higher welfare.
- Welfare also depends on distribution, the environment and quality of life.
- Give two things GDP omits.
- Why can GDP rise while welfare falls?
- What does the ONS measure in UK national wellbeing?
- How does subjective happiness relate to real income?
