Two development channels
- Trade and investment are two of the main channels through which developed and developing countries interact.
- Both can raise incomes and build productive capacity in poorer economies.
- Both can also create dependency, so their effects need to be weighed carefully.
Trade as a route to development
- Trade lets a developing country specialise according to its comparative advantage and sell to much larger world markets.
- Exports earn the foreign exchange needed to import capital goods and technology, which raises future productivity.
- Access to bigger markets lets firms exploit economies of scale, and exposure to competition can raise efficiency.
- Export-led growth has helped several economies raise incomes rapidly.
- South Korea and, more recently, Vietnam grew quickly by exporting manufactured goods such as electronics and clothing to world markets.
- Export earnings paid for imports of machinery and technology, which raised productivity and wages over time.
Barriers and risks in trade
Terms of trade: the ratio of a country's average export prices to its average import prices, usually shown as an index number.
- Many developing economies depend on a narrow range of primary commodities, such as Zambia's reliance on copper or Ghana's on cocoa.
- Primary product prices are volatile, because inelastic demand and supply mean small shifts cause large price swings, making export earnings unstable.
- The terms of trade for many primary exporters have tended to decline over time, so a given volume of exports buys fewer imported manufactures each year.
- Developed countries' protectionism, such as tariffs and farm subsidies, can shut developing-country exports out of rich markets.
- Reliance on a few exports leaves an economy vulnerable, so diversification into manufacturing and services is often needed.
- Suppose a copper exporter starts with export and import price indices of 100, then its export price index falls to 110 while its import price index rises to 125.
- The terms of trade fall from 100 to 88, a deterioration of 12%, so each unit of exports now buys about 12% fewer imports and the capacity to import is squeezed.
Investment flows between countries
Foreign direct investment (FDI): investment that gives a firm a lasting controlling interest in productive assets in another country.
Portfolio investment: the purchase of financial assets such as shares and bonds without control over the firms, which can be withdrawn rapidly.
- Developing economies often have a savings gap, too little domestic saving to fund the investment they need.
- Foreign investment can add to domestic savings and fund capital projects that raise productive capacity.
- Foreign direct investment (FDI) brings capital, technology and management skills through a lasting stake in local production, for example Toyota building a plant abroad.
- Portfolio investment provides finance but can flow out quickly and destabilise the economy.
- Much cross-border investment is carried out by multinational companies such as Apple or Unilever, which can create jobs and transfer technology.
Weighing trade and investment
- Trade and investment can raise incomes, employment and productive capacity.
- But the gains can be uneven, and reliance on foreign capital or a few exports creates dependency.
- Volatile capital flows and the repatriation of profits to foreign owners can offset the benefits.
- On balance, trade and investment can drive development, but the outcome depends on diversification, the terms of trade and the strength of domestic institutions.
- Explain the chain from trade and investment to higher incomes before you evaluate.
- Weigh the gains against volatility, dependency and declining terms of trade.
- Support a judgement with the country's export structure and institutions.
- Do not assume trade and investment always benefit a developing economy.
- Distinguish stable, long-term FDI from volatile, short-term portfolio (hot money) flows.
- How can trade promote development?
- What is the terms of trade problem faced by primary-commodity exporters?
- Why does a savings gap create a need for foreign investment?
- What is the difference between FDI and portfolio investment?
- Give one risk of relying on trade and investment for development.