Validity
The extent to which a measure actually assesses what it claims to measure.
- Validity is how far a study measures what it intended to measure.
- A valid study gives results that really reflect what is being studied.
- Validity is about accuracy, whereas reliability is about consistency.
- Reliability asks "same result each time?"; validity asks "measuring the right thing?"
- A study can be reliable but still not valid.
Objectivity and Subjectivity
- Objectivity
- Data that is not affected by the researcher's personal opinions or feelings, so it is unbiased.
- Subjectivity
- Data that is shaped by personal opinions or feelings, so it can be biased.
- More objective measures usually give more valid, trustworthy findings.
- Counting how many words someone recalls is objective: anyone would get the same number.
- Rating how "creative" a story is by opinion is subjective: two markers might disagree.
How Objectivity Protects Validity
- If something other than what you meant to measure affects the results, validity drops.
- A biased, subjective measure can make results reflect the researcher's view rather than the participant's behaviour.
- Keeping measures objective and well controlled protects validity.
- Do not treat validity and reliability as the same thing.
- Do not assume a consistent result must also be a valid one.
Spotting Validity Problems
- Ask whether the study really measured what it set out to (its aim), not something else.
- Ask whether the measure was objective or shaped by the researcher's opinion.
- Explain how that raises or lowers validity; an 'explain' answer needs the why, not just the label.
- What is validity?
- What is the difference between subjectivity and objectivity?
- How does validity differ from reliability?
- Why is objective data usually more valid than subjective data?