Applying Open and Closed Questions
- In this skill you choose the best question format for a described aim.
- The choice depends on whether you want numbers or detail.
- Open questions give detail; closed questions give data you can count.
- Need to count and compare? Reach for closed questions.
- Need to understand feelings or reasons? Reach for open questions.
A Worked Example
- Aim: to find out what pupils think of a new ban on phones during the school day.
- To count how many pupils support or oppose it, use a closed question.
- To learn why they feel that way, use an open question.
- A single survey can carry both, so you get the numbers and the reasons.
- Closed: "Do you support the phone ban? Yes, no or unsure."
- Open: "How has the phone ban changed your school day?"
Matching Format to the Aim
- If the aim needs figures or comparison, closed questions fit.
- If the aim needs depth or explanation, open questions fit.
- Always say what data your chosen format will produce.
- Do not choose open questions when the aim just needs simple, countable data.
- Do not choose closed questions when the aim is to explore reasons.
A Step-by-Step Routine
- Decide whether the aim in the scenario wants numbers or detail.
- Pick closed for countable data or open for detail to match it.
- Justify it by naming the data it gives (quantitative or qualitative); that reason scores separately from the choice.
- Which format suits an aim that needs countable data?
- Which format suits an aim that needs to explore reasons?
- For an aim measuring how often pupils exercise each week, which format fits and why?
- Why might a survey use both open and closed questions?