Applying Self-Report Methods
Self-report
A method in which people give information about themselves, for example by answering an anonymous questionnaire or interview about crimes they have committed.
- In this skill you pick a questionnaire or an interview for a given aim, then justify your choice.
- Ask what the aim needs most: numbers from many people, or depth from a few.
- Then back your choice with a strength and an honest weakness.
- A questionnaire suits large numbers and quick, comparable data.
- An interview suits smaller numbers and detailed, in-depth data.
A Worked Example
- Aim: to find out how Year 7 pupils are coping with the move up to secondary school.
- To survey the whole of Year 7 quickly, a questionnaire fits.
- To understand a handful of anxious pupils in depth, an interview fits better.
- Whichever you pick, tie the reason straight back to the aim.
- "A questionnaire suits this aim because it can reach every Year 7 form in a single morning."
- "An interview would reveal richer detail about why a few pupils are struggling, but from far fewer people."
Weighing the Two Methods
- A questionnaire is quicker and reaches more people, but gives you less depth.
- An interview gives more depth, but takes longer and reaches fewer people.
- Both can be dented by social desirability bias, where people answer to look good.
- Do not just name a method; always justify it against the aim.
- Do not ignore the weakness of your chosen method; name it and say how you would limit it.
A Step-by-Step Routine
- State what the aim in the scenario needs most: numbers from many, or depth from a few.
- Choose the questionnaire or interview that delivers that.
- Give one strength and one weakness tied to that aim; the justification linked to the aim scores separately from naming the method.
- Which self-report method suits reaching a large sample quickly?
- Which method suits gathering in-depth data from a few people?
- For an aim exploring why a few pupils feel lonely at lunchtime, which would you choose and why?
- Why should you always name a weakness of your chosen method?