Deciding If a Study Is an Experiment
- Here you apply the definition of an experiment to a study you have not seen before.
- Ask whether one variable was manipulated to see its effect on another.
- Then check that the study was run under controlled conditions.
- The test is whether an IV was manipulated and a DV measured under control.
- If yes, it is an experiment; if not, it is another research method.
A Worked Example
- One class revises with a new app while another revises as normal, then both sit the same test.
- IV manipulated: app versus normal revision.
- DV measured: the test score.
- Conditions controlled: the same test and the same time limit, so this is an experiment.
- Change the study to "researchers simply record how many hours pupils revise".
- Nothing is manipulated now, so this version is not an experiment.
When It Is Not an Experiment
- If the researcher only watches or records behaviour, no IV is manipulated.
- If they only ask questions, they are gathering self-report, not running an experiment.
- No manipulation means no experiment, however carefully the study is run.
- Do not call a study an experiment just because it produces numbers.
- The deciding factor is whether an IV was manipulated, not the type of data.
How to Answer These Questions
- Name the exact variable changed in the scenario; lifting it from the study is a separate mark.
- Name the exact outcome they measured in that scenario.
- State your decision, then justify it with those details from the study, not the textbook definition.
- What one feature must a study have to count as an experiment?
- A study records people's height and exam results, with nothing changed. Is it an experiment?
- Why is producing numbers not enough to make a study an experiment?
- How would you justify calling a study an experiment?