What Counts as an Extraneous Variable
Extraneous variable
Any variable other than the independent variable that could affect the dependent variable. If it is not controlled, it offers an alternative explanation for the results.
- An extraneous variable is any variable, other than the independent variable, that could affect the dependent variable.
- It is an unwanted influence you never set out to study.
- Leave it uncontrolled and it can push the DV up or down, muddying what your results really mean.
- You want only the IV to differ between your conditions.
- Anything else that slips in and could nudge the DV is extraneous.
Situational and Participant Variables
- Situational variables
- Features of the setting, such as the temperature or noise in a school hall on the day of testing.
- Participant variables
- Differences between the people, such as their age, mood or how much sleep they had the night before.
- Situational: one class sits a memory test in a hot, noisy school hall while another sits it in a cool, quiet classroom.
- Participant: by chance, one group contains far more early risers who are sharper in the morning.
Why They Threaten Your Conclusion
- An uncontrolled extraneous variable offers an alternative explanation for any difference you find.
- You can no longer be sure that the IV, rather than the extra variable, caused the change in the DV.
- That uncertainty weakens the cause-and-effect claim the study was meant to make.
- What is an extraneous variable?
- Give one situational and one participant variable for a memory test held in a school hall.
- Why do you want only the IV to differ between the conditions?
- Why does an uncontrolled extraneous variable weaken a conclusion?