The Control Group as a Baseline
Control group
A group of participants who do not receive the experimental treatment and who act as a baseline against which the experimental group is compared.
- The control group acts as a baseline, showing what happens with no treatment.
- You then compare the experimental group against this baseline.
- The gap between them is taken as the effect of the IV.
- A baseline gives you a fixed point to measure the effect against.
- No baseline means no way of knowing how big the effect really is.
Why a Comparison Is Needed
- Without a control group, there is nothing to compare the results with.
- You could not tell whether the result was caused by the IV or would have happened anyway.
- The control group rules out that the change was just normal behaviour.
- A group takes a new memory drug and improves over a week.
- Without a no-drug group, the improvement could just be practice, not the drug.
What the Comparison Lets You Say
- A clear difference between the groups points to the IV as the cause.
- The comparison helps isolate the IV's effect from other influences.
- If the groups turn out similar, the IV may have had little effect.
- Do not say a result shows the IV works without comparing it to a control.
- The comparison is only fair if the groups were alike to begin with.
Using the Baseline
- Take the control group's no-treatment result as the baseline.
- Compare the experimental group's result against that baseline.
- Read the difference as the IV's effect; the control rules out that it would have happened anyway, which is the point an 'explain' question wants.
- Why is a control group called a baseline?
- Why can you not attribute an effect to the IV without a comparison group?
- In the memory-drug example, what could explain the improvement without a control group?
- What does a large difference between the groups suggest?