The Argument Against the Theory
- Self-determination theory says that meeting competence, relatedness and autonomy drives you to exercise.
- The problem is that even a highly motivated person runs into real barriers that stop them.
- This makes the theory an incomplete explanation of who actually exercises.
- The theory locates motivation inside the person, in the three needs.
- Environmental barriers sit outside the person and can block exercise anyway.
Environmental Barriers That Stop Motivated People Exercising
- Lack of time
- A packed timetable of school, a part-time job and revision can leave no room to train, however keen you are.
- Health issues
- Injury, illness or a disability can physically stop you exercising even when your motivation is high.
- Social limitations
- No safe space to train, no money for a gym, or no one to go with can block exercise you genuinely want to do.
- Think of a sixth-former who loves five-a-side football.
- She feels competent, has mates to play with and chooses to go, so her three needs are met.
- But she works Saturday shifts and lives an hour from the nearest pitch.
- Her motivation is high, yet time and access stop her playing, which the theory struggles to explain.
A Limitation of the Theory
- The theory explains exercise almost entirely through internal motivation, the three needs.
- Barriers such as time, health and access sit outside the person, so the theory largely ignores them.
- As a result it can predict exercise that the environment then blocks.
- Do not throw the theory out, because it still explains internal motivation well.
- Do remember that motivation without the chance to act does not produce exercise.
A Balanced Conclusion
- The theory explains why people want to exercise better than it explains whether they can.
- A full account of exercise needs both strong motivation and a real opportunity to act on it.
- What is the main argument against the theory in the context of exercise?
- Name two environmental barriers to exercise.
- Why can a motivated person still fail to exercise?
- What does a balanced conclusion about the theory say?