Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·5.5.4 Argument against self-determination theory
Sign up

5.5.4 Argument against self-determination theory

The Argument Against the Theory

  1. Self-determination theory says that meeting competence, relatedness and autonomy drives you to exercise.
  2. The problem is that even a highly motivated person runs into real barriers that stop them.
  3. This makes the theory an incomplete explanation of who actually exercises.
Key Idea
  • The theory locates motivation inside the person, in the three needs.
  • Environmental barriers sit outside the person and can block exercise anyway.

Environmental Barriers That Stop Motivated People Exercising

  1. Lack of time
    1. A packed timetable of school, a part-time job and revision can leave no room to train, however keen you are.
  2. Health issues
    1. Injury, illness or a disability can physically stop you exercising even when your motivation is high.
  3. Social limitations
    1. No safe space to train, no money for a gym, or no one to go with can block exercise you genuinely want to do.
Example
  • Think of a sixth-former who loves five-a-side football.
  • She feels competent, has mates to play with and chooses to go, so her three needs are met.
  • But she works Saturday shifts and lives an hour from the nearest pitch.
  • Her motivation is high, yet time and access stop her playing, which the theory struggles to explain.

A Limitation of the Theory

  1. The theory explains exercise almost entirely through internal motivation, the three needs.
  2. Barriers such as time, health and access sit outside the person, so the theory largely ignores them.
  3. As a result it can predict exercise that the environment then blocks.
Common Mistake
  • Do not throw the theory out, because it still explains internal motivation well.
  • Do remember that motivation without the chance to act does not produce exercise.

A Balanced Conclusion

  1. The theory explains why people want to exercise better than it explains whether they can.
  2. A full account of exercise needs both strong motivation and a real opportunity to act on it.
Self review
  • What is the main argument against the theory in the context of exercise?
  • Name two environmental barriers to exercise.
  • Why can a motivated person still fail to exercise?
  • What does a balanced conclusion about the theory say?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 5.5.4 Argument against self-determination theory by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

8 minute activity

Start lesson

Self-determination theory suggests that people exercise when three psychological needs are met: competence, relatedness and autonomy. Competence means feeling capable, relatedness means feeling connected to others, and autonomy means feeling that exercise is freely chosen.

The argument against the theory is that motivation alone may not produce exercise. A person can have strong internal motivation but still be prevented by barriers outside their control.

Therefore, the theory may explain why people want to exercise better than it explains whether they are actually able to exercise.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

12 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

1 mark

Imogen chooses which activities to do in her exercise class, notices that her performance is improving and feels supported by the other people there. She wants to continue exercising, but an illness means that she is physically unable to take part for several weeks.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

22 flashcards

Practice flashcards

Which three needs does self-determination theory say drive exercise?

5.5.4 Argument against self-determination theory Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /5.5.4 Argument against self-determination theory

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 5.5.4 Argument against self-determination theory: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides