The Argument Against Gregory's Theory
- Gregory says perception is entirely learned, built from stored knowledge and past experience.
- The main objection is that this ignores the role of nature: some perception appears to be innate, present before there is any experience to learn from.
- A purely nurture-based theory cannot easily explain abilities a person seems to be born with.
- If perception were only learned, a newborn with no experience should barely perceive at all.
- Evidence that very young babies already perceive points to an innate, nature side that Gregory leaves out.
Evidence That Some Perception Is Innate
- On the visual cliff, babies avoid an apparent drop as soon as they can crawl, before they have had time to learn about depth and falling.
- This suggests depth perception is at least partly innate, not built up purely from experience.
- Gregory's theory struggles to explain such early ability, because it says perception has to be learned first.
- A crawling baby stops at the edge of the visual cliff and refuses to cross the apparent drop, even when their mother calls.
- They have had no chance to learn about heights, so the ability looks built in rather than acquired.
The Problem of the First Hypothesis
- If every perception needs a hypothesis built from past experience, it is unclear how a newborn forms its very first one.
- With no stored knowledge to draw on, that first guess has nowhere to come from, which points to some innate starting point.
- This is the nature side that a purely constructivist account cannot supply.
- State the argument as the spec puts it: Gregory ignores the role of nature in perception.
- You do not have to reject him; most psychologists accept perception is both innate and learned, nature and nurture together.
Making the Argument in the Exam
- State Gregory's claim: perception is learned from experience, on the nurture side.
- Give the counter: it ignores nature, since some perception is innate.
- Back it with evidence such as babies perceiving depth on the visual cliff.
- What does the spec say Gregory's theory ignores?
- How does the visual cliff suggest depth perception is innate?
- Why is the first perceptual hypothesis a problem for a nurture-only theory?
- What is the balanced conclusion about nature and nurture?