The Limits of Social Learning Theory
- Social learning theory explains helping entirely through the environment, meaning models and vicarious reinforcement.
- Critics argue that the environment is not entirely responsible for prosocial behaviour.
- Biological factors also shape how helpful you are, and the theory leaves them out.
- Helping is not only learnt from watching models.
- Hormones, neurotransmitters, brain areas and genes all play a part.
Where Biology Comes In
- The neurotransmitter serotonin affects mood and impulse control, which influence whether you step in to help.
- The hormone oxytocin supports trust and bonding, which makes prosocial acts more likely.
- Brain areas linked to empathy become active when you see someone in need.
- Genes contribute as well, so part of the tendency to help is inherited rather than watched.
- Identical twins raised in different homes still tend to be similarly helpful.
- Because they did not share the same models, learning alone cannot explain the likeness.
A Balanced Judgement
- Social learning theory explains modelled helping and media effects convincingly.
- But it cannot account for the differences in helping between people who saw the same models.
- The fairest conclusion is that both nature and nurture shape prosocial behaviour.
- Do not throw out the theory, because it still explains learnt helping well.
- Do not claim the environment alone is responsible, because that ignores clear biological evidence.
Why This Matters for the Theory
- A full explanation of helping has to combine learnt behaviour with biology.
- That is why social learning theory is treated as part of the picture, not the whole of it.
- What is the main argument against social learning theory?
- Name two biological factors that influence helping.
- Why does the twin evidence challenge a purely learnt account?
- What is the balanced conclusion about nature and nurture?