Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·2.4.7 Argument against psychodynamic theory of dreaming
Sign up

2.4.7 Argument against psychodynamic theory of dreaming

The Argument Against the Theory

  1. The psychodynamic theory relies on interpreting a dream's symbols to uncover its hidden meaning.
  2. The main objection is that this interpretation is subjective, resting on the interpreter's own opinions and feelings.
  3. So the same dream can be read in more than one way, with no way to say which reading is right.
Key Idea
  • A dream symbol has no fixed, agreed meaning of its own.
  • Whatever it is taken to mean depends on the person doing the interpreting.

Why the Interpretation Is Subjective

  1. Because a symbol carries no set meaning, what it stands for is a matter of opinion.
  2. Two therapists can look at the same dream and reach two completely different meanings.
  3. There is no objective test to settle which is correct, so the interpreter's own bias shapes the answer.
Example
  • One therapist might read a dream of falling as a fear of failing an exam.
  • Another might read the very same dream as guilt about letting someone down, and neither can be proved wrong.

Why This Weakens the Theory

  1. Since interpretations cannot be checked against any objective standard, the theory is very hard to test scientifically.
  2. The meaning you get out depends on who is doing the interpreting, so the findings are open to bias.
  3. That makes the psychodynamic account of dreaming insightful but difficult to treat as scientific.
Common Mistake
  • The against is a plain statement, not a study: interpreting dream symbols is subjective, shaped by the interpreter's own opinions.
  • Back it with one dream read two ways, so it is not left as a bare assertion.

Making the Argument in the Exam

  1. State the claim under attack: dream symbols can be interpreted to reveal a hidden meaning.
  2. Give the against: that interpretation is subjective and biased, so there is no way to confirm which reading is right.
  3. Anchor it with one dream read two ways; in a for-and-against item, leaving this side out caps you at Max 3.
Self review
  • What is the main argument against the psychodynamic theory of dreaming?
  • Why is interpreting a dream symbol described as subjective?
  • Why can two therapists disagree about the same dream?
  • Why does this subjectivity make the theory hard to test?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 2.4.7 Argument against psychodynamic theory of dreaming by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

7 minute activity

Start lesson

The psychodynamic theory claims that dreams contain hidden meanings. Dream symbols are interpreted to reveal unconscious thoughts, wishes, or conflicts.

The main argument against this theory is that interpreting symbols is subjective. A symbol has no fixed, agreed meaning, so its meaning depends on the opinions and feelings of the person interpreting it.

Because different interpretations may be possible, there is no reliable way to decide which interpretation is correct.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

5 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

4 marks

A client gives three therapists the same report of a dream in which the client is standing on a stage and speaking into a microphone that produces no sound. Each therapist interprets the dream independently.

TherapistOpinion held before reading the dream reportInterpretation of the silent microphone
AmaraDreams mainly reflect worries about achievementThe client fears being unsuccessful at work
HughesDreams mainly reflect difficulties in family communicationThe client feels unable to speak openly to their family
ChenDreams mainly reflect concerns about social judgementThe client fears that friends will not listen to them

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

20 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What does the psychodynamic theory rely on when explaining dreams?

2.4.7 Argument against psychodynamic theory of dreaming Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /2.4.7 Argument against psychodynamic theory of dreaming

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 2.4.7 Argument against psychodynamic theory of dreaming: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides