The Argument Against the Model
- Each theory in this topic has one argument for it and one against it, and you need both.
- The argument for the model is the Craik and Tulving study, which is covered separately.
- The single argument against it is that it cannot explain the limited capacity of memory.
- The model explains how well something is remembered, but not how much can be held.
- That leaves out a real and obvious feature of memory: its limits.
Why Capacity Is a Problem for the Model
- The model is built entirely around depth of processing, so it explains how well something is remembered.
- It says nothing about how much information memory can hold at any one time.
- Yet memory clearly does have limits, and short-term memory in particular can only hold a small amount at once.
- Because the model has no way to account for that limit, it gives an incomplete picture of how memory works.
- The multi-store model, by contrast, builds in a short-term store with a limited capacity.
- It can explain why you can only hold a few new items in mind at once, which the levels of processing model cannot.
Using the Argument in an Answer
- State the weakness as a plain point: the model cannot explain the limited capacity of memory.
- Explain why that matters, since short-term memory clearly has limits the model leaves out entirely.
- If the item asks for one argument for and one against, pair this with the Craik and Tulving study, because giving only one side caps the answer at three of the four marks.
- What is the one argument against the levels of processing model?
- What can the model not explain about memory?
- Which store shows most clearly that memory has a limited capacity?
- Which model can explain limited capacity, unlike this one?