Out of season by the sea
Source A: an original imagined account by a winter visitor to a coastal town.
I preferred the promenade after the summer stalls had closed. Without the bright signs competing for the next purchase, I noticed the long line of the rail and the sound of the sea beyond it. The town seemed to have put down something heavy.
We walked slowly and found one open café. Its windows gave us a place to watch the weather, and the owner had time for a conversation which might not have happened beside a queue. I liked being a visitor without feeling that every step had been arranged to collect me.
I know that my quiet weekend was not the town’s whole winter. The closed kiosks were somebody’s work, and I would go home to a different routine. Still, a place can offer something valuable when it is not performing its busiest version. I hope its quieter months can be appreciated without being remade as another sort of crowded season.
Source B: an original imagined letter by a resident of that coastal town.
Visitors sometimes tell us that winter is when the town becomes itself again. I understand the appeal of the empty promenade, but the phrase makes the people who work through summer sound like a costume we are fortunate to remove.
When the stalls close, some residents lose hours of work and some familiar meeting places disappear until spring. The open café matters to us because it is a place to see somebody on an ordinary Tuesday, not only an attractive shelter during a weekend away. Quiet can be restful; it can also mean that an evening has fewer possibilities.
I do not want every shutter replaced by another attraction. I would like a conversation about which services and shared places the town needs throughout the year. Let people enjoy the sea without assuming that fewer visitors automatically makes a fuller life for those who remain.
Compare how Sources A and B view the coastal town outside its busy season.
40 exam-style questions on Oxford AQA IGCSE English Language 5.1.2 R2: Collate and synthesise across sources. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.