Skip to content

Course home

Question bank·2.3.7 AO3 in Section A
Sign up

2.3.7 AO3 in Section A

MediumHard
1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556575859606162636465666768697071727374757677787980
Question 74

What we keep working

Text One: A convert, apparently

An original personal account by a visitor to a community repair workshop.

I arrived at the repair workshop carrying a table lamp and left announcing that I had become a convert. This was a confident conclusion from someone who had spent most of the afternoon watching another person hold the screwdriver.

The lamp had belonged to my grandmother. Its shade leaned slightly to the left, however carefully it was adjusted, and the switch had recently begun to work only after several attempts. I could have replaced it. Indeed, I had already looked at new lamps and discovered that they were brighter, straighter and cheaper than I expected. Instead, I wrapped the old one in a towel and carried it across town.

The workshop occupied a hall usually hired for children’s parties. Beneath paper decorations, volunteers had arranged separate tables for electrical items, clothes and bicycles. The atmosphere suggested that everything entering the room would eventually be returned to usefulness. A repaired toaster was greeted with applause. Nobody applauded the owner of a radio who was advised not to use it again, although he thanked the volunteer just as warmly.

At the lamp table, Arun asked what I thought was wrong. I said, ‘The switch,’ because this was the only part whose name I knew. He did not immediately correct me. Instead, he showed me how he would test the lamp and explained each result. When he offered me the screwdriver, I turned it so cautiously that the screw appeared to tighten itself out of politeness.

I liked the patience of the process: the labelled trays, the careful questions and the refusal to pretend that a guess was knowledge. Yet I also liked being able to surrender the difficult parts. Whenever Arun paused, I became absorbed in my cup of tea. I had imagined that repair would make me independent. In practice, it made me grateful that somebody else had learned what I had not.

The lamp eventually shone without persuasion from me, though the shade still leaned. I told several people that repairing it had been more satisfying than buying a perfect replacement. That was true. It was also true that, once home, I left it unplugged for three evenings before trusting the switch.

It now stands beside my chair, casting an uneven circle of light. I continue to describe the workshop enthusiastically. I have even promised to return with the kitchen clock, although it has been waiting beside the front door for two months. Conversion, like repair, may be less complete than it first appears.

Text Two: No miracles on the workbench

An original article by a volunteer at a community repair workshop.

People sometimes place an object on my workbench as if it were an injured bird. They tell me where it came from, who gave it to them and how long it has been silent. Then they watch my hands for evidence of a miracle.

I am not sentimental about broken objects. Some cannot be repaired responsibly. Others would cost more to restore than their owners expect, and occasionally the most useful thing I can offer is a clear explanation of why an item should not be used. A workshop that promises success for everything will soon become careless with both objects and people.

Nevertheless, I remember particular repairs. There was the desk fan that began turning so quietly that its owner leaned closer to check it was moving. There was a toy train whose wheels completed one uncertain circuit while three generations of a family watched. I keep a notebook of these cases because recurring faults are useful to record. The fact that I also write down the owners’ reactions is, I tell myself, merely thorough administration.

The public usually notices the moment an object works again. Volunteers notice the stages before it: finding the fault, choosing whether to continue and admitting when an attempted solution has changed nothing. These decisions require more judgement than the final turn of a screw. They are also difficult to celebrate. Nobody photographs a careful refusal.

A repair workshop should not teach people that every possession must be preserved. That would turn thrift into another form of waste, with cupboards filled by objects kept through guilt. What we can teach is attention. An owner who learns why a zip fails or where a chair joint has loosened may make a better decision, even if that decision is replacement.

This is why I ask visitors to remain at the table rather than leave an item with me. Some become impatient with explanations and glance repeatedly towards the refreshment table. Others begin by saying that they are ‘hopeless’ and finish by fitting the final piece themselves. The object may be repaired, but the more durable change is often in the person looking at it.

At the end of each session, I clear the workbench. Failed parts go into the correct recycling containers, useful components are labelled and tools return to their outlines on the wall. In the bottom drawer, however, is the cracked spring from the first clock I ever failed to mend. I keep it for demonstration purposes, although I have never demonstrated it to anyone.

Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about repairing damaged household objects.

Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.

[15]
Markscheme

2.3.7 AO3 in Section A Questions

  1. IGCSE
  2. /English Language
  3. /2.3.7 AO3 in Section A

102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.

More questions