A forecast made of fragments
Text One: The weather inside the fence
An original account by a visitor to a weather-observation station.
I expected the weather station to command its hill. The instruments stood inside a square fence, their white surfaces bright against the grass, while a mast lifted its cups into the wind. I had imagined a place from which the whole sky could be understood. Instead, the station seemed to be collecting it in pieces.
Our guide read the temperature, wind speed and pressure from separate instruments. Each measurement was precise, yet the weather surrounding us refused to appear equally orderly. Sunshine reached one side of the hill while rain concealed the far end of the valley. I asked which condition would count as the weather. The guide replied that the station recorded what happened at its instruments, at the agreed time and in the agreed way.
At first, this sounded like an admission of failure. I wanted the measurements to settle an argument about whether our afternoon walk would remain dry. The station offered observations rather than promises. Even its rain container, emptied and checked by hand, seemed unexpectedly modest beside the size of the clouds.
Then I noticed how carefully the guide replaced its lid and entered the reading in the logbook. The smallness of the task was its strength. Nobody could measure every field or follow each cloud, but the same careful action, repeated here and elsewhere, allowed separate moments to become part of a longer record. Precision did not mean knowing everything. It meant being exact about what had been observed.
When we left, the logbook contained another completed entry and the valley still contained several kinds of weather. I did not know whether we would avoid the rain. However, when the wind cooled and the distant trees became indistinct, I paid attention before making my guess.
Text Two: At nine, whatever the sky is doing
An original account by a weather-station technician.
Visitors often arrive expecting the instruments to produce a forecast while they watch. They hear a wind reading and wait for someone to announce what will happen next. Forecasting uses observations, but a station like ours begins with a less dramatic responsibility: the nine o’clock reading must mean the same kind of thing today as it did yesterday.
That requirement shapes the work. A thermometer is not moved into the sun because the morning feels cold. A wind measurement is not delayed until a gust has passed. If leaves enter the rain container, I record the problem rather than quietly choosing a more convenient result. Consistency can look unimaginative, but without it a long record becomes a collection of private decisions.
This does not make the work automatic. Instruments fail, surroundings change and an unusual result may be either important or wrong. When a reading differs sharply from those before it, I check the equipment and the written record. I do not erase the result merely because it is surprising. Nor do I preserve it merely because a machine produced it. The observation needs judgement, but the judgement must remain visible in the record.
The public sometimes treats a precise value as a claim of certainty. It is only a claim about the scale on which something was recorded. Our instrument can give the wind speed here without describing the sheltered road below. A complete line in the logbook may still represent incomplete knowledge of the day.
I value visits because they show that weather records are made rather than simply received. Yet I am cautious when someone leaves repeating a single measurement as though it describes the whole district. The station reduces uncertainty by measuring carefully; it does not remove uncertainty from the sky. The most useful visitor is not the one who trusts every reading without question, but the one who understands what question that reading can answer.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about the value and limitations of recording weather.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.