What counted as repaired
Text One: The chair we did not finish
An original personal essay about volunteering at a community repair workshop.
I arrived at the repair workshop expecting to be useful in ways that could be counted. By the end of the afternoon, I imagined, several broken objects would be working again, and each completed job would provide a small, definite victory.
The first visitor brought a wooden chair with a loose back. I reached for the tools, eager to begin, but an experienced volunteer called Mara asked the owner how the chair was used and whether it had been repaired before. Her questions seemed unnecessarily slow. The chair was obviously there to be fixed; talking about it felt like postponing the real work.
Once we examined it carefully, Mara found that one of the joints had split. A replacement piece would be needed, and we did not have one of the right size. I waited for her to attempt a temporary solution. Instead, she explained the problem, described what a future repair would involve and advised the owner not to use the chair in the meantime.
I expected the owner to be disappointed. She was relieved. She had considered forcing the joint together herself and said that knowing what not to do had saved her from making the damage worse. She left without a repaired chair but with a clear next step.
Later, I tightened a handle on a drawer in a few minutes. The owner thanked me, and I enjoyed the simple success. Yet the quick repair made me reconsider the chair. One job had ended neatly; the other had required patience, honesty and the willingness to stop. It no longer seemed fair to call only one of them useful.
At the end of the session, the chair remained unfinished. I had arrived believing that worthwhile work always produced a completed object. I left understanding that sometimes the most responsible result is an accurate explanation and no repair at all.
Text Two: Success beyond the completed repair
An original article by the coordinator of a community repair project.
People often ask how many objects our volunteers repair during a session. It is a reasonable question. Completed repairs are encouraging, and keeping an object in use can be an important result. However, a single total can conceal more than it reveals.
Not all repair tasks are equal. Replacing a loose fastening may take a few minutes, while investigating damage inside a piece of furniture may occupy most of an afternoon. If organisers focus only on the number completed, volunteers may feel pressure to select easy tasks or hurry through difficult ones.
A worthwhile session can have several outcomes. An object may be repaired fully, made ready for later work or examined so that its owner understands the problem. In some cases, the responsible decision is to stop because the necessary part, skill or time is unavailable. Refusing to improvise is not the same as refusing to help.
This does not mean that good intentions excuse poor results. Volunteers should explain what they have done, admit the limits of their knowledge and avoid promising more than they can provide. Owners deserve enough information to decide what happens next.
We also encourage volunteers to work with owners rather than silently taking objects away from them. A person who understands a repair may be able to recognise the same problem in future. The exchange of knowledge can therefore matter alongside the condition of the object itself.
Success should still be examined carefully, but it requires more than a completed-repair total. We should ask whether the owner received honest guidance, whether the object has a sensible next step and whether the volunteer worked patiently. A community repair project is valuable not because every object leaves ready for use, but because each person leaves better able to make a responsible decision.
Compare the writers’ ideas and perspectives on what makes a community repair project worthwhile, and the ways these are conveyed.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.