Choosing from the rail
Text One: The clothes I can try
An original personal essay about buying second-hand clothes.
I entered the second-hand shop carrying a list of things I needed for a new job. Trousers, two shirts, a coat suitable for rain. It was a practical expedition until I saw the orange waistcoat beside the door. Nothing on my list had prepared an argument against it.
In a department store, I usually begin by finding the section which is supposed to contain people like me. Here, the rails offered no such comfortable prediction. A formal dress stood beside a running jacket. Sizes disagreed with one another. I tried on three shirts marked the same size and emerged as three differently proportioned people.
This was inconvenient. It was also unexpectedly freeing. I could not select an outfit simply by following a picture of the sort of person I hoped to become. I had to notice whether a sleeve pulled, whether I liked the colour and whether I could imagine wearing the thing on a wet Monday.
The assistant found the trousers I had missed and pointed out a loose button before I paid. We discussed whether I could mend it. The small reduction in price was welcome, but so was being asked what I could manage rather than being told that the bargain explained everything.
I left with most of the list and without the waistcoat. There was no grand lesson in refusing it. I still liked it. What I valued was having considered clothes one at a time, without buying the complete future which a window display so often appears to promise.
Text Two: The work before the rail
An original article by a second-hand clothing shop manager.
Customers sometimes describe our shop as a place where clothes tell stories. I do not mind the phrase, provided nobody expects the stories to do the sorting. Before an item reaches the rail, someone has checked its seams, looked for stains and decided whether it can be sold in its present condition.
A donated coat may be valuable to us, but an unusable bag of clothes is not automatically a gift. We have limited storage and people who must handle everything that arrives. The most helpful donation is one which has been considered before it crosses the door.
I enjoy seeing an item find a new owner. Yesterday a customer tried three pairs of trousers, found one that fitted and returned the others to their hangers. It was an unremarkable transaction, and a good one. The trousers did not need to represent a whole philosophy. They needed to fit, last and be worth their price.
That does not mean memory is unwelcome. A woman recently told us that a coat resembled one her father wore. We talked for several minutes. She did not buy it, and I did not expect her to. A shop can contain more than sales without forgetting that sales pay its bills.
I would like people to buy second-hand clothes because they can be good clothes. Enjoy the unexpected colour, the unusual cut, the pleasure of finding something you will use. Then check the fastening and the washing instructions. Another life for an object begins more reliably with a sound zip than with an attractive sentence about its past.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about the value of second-hand clothing.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.