The marks we keep
Text One: What the table remembered
An original account by a furniture conservator.
The table arrived with its legs wrapped in blankets and a note tied to the handle of one drawer: ‘Please make it beautiful again.’ It was already beautiful, although not in the way its owners expected.
A pale ring spread across one corner where a hot dish had once stood. Near the drawer, a line of blue ink disappeared into the grain. The surface carried dozens of scratches, some deep enough to catch a fingernail. The family described these marks as damage. I saw a record of meals, homework and hurried decisions.
This did not mean that I intended to leave the table untouched. One joint had opened so widely that the top shifted whenever anyone leaned on it. A drawer had swollen and could no longer be closed. Conservation is not the worship of decay. I repaired the joint, adjusted the drawer and removed a layer of dirt that belonged to nobody’s treasured past.
The difficult question was how far to continue. Sanding the surface would have made it evenly bright, but it would also have removed the ink and softened the scratches. I cleaned a small area and invited the family to look. At first, they stared at the remaining marks with polite disappointment. Then one of them recognised the ink as the result of a leaking pen used during revision for an important examination.
We agreed to keep the surface largely as it was. The table left my workshop stable, clean and ready to be used, but not disguised as a younger object. Its marks were no longer failures that I had neglected to correct. They had become part of what the family had asked me to protect.
A restorer can make an object look new. The more demanding task is deciding whether newness is really the most truthful result.
Text Two: A table is not an exhibit
An original personal essay by the owner of an inherited kitchen table.
When my aunt gave me her kitchen table, three different people warned me not to spoil its character. By ‘character’, they meant every stain, dent and rough edge it had collected during forty years of family meals.
I understood their concern. I remembered sitting beneath that table as a child, building a house from the chairs while the adults talked above me. One dent had been made when a heavy bowl fell during a crowded lunch. A dark patch near the centre came from a candle that burned lower than anyone noticed. These marks belonged to stories I wanted to keep.
They also belonged to a table that was unpleasant to use. One leg rocked on the floor. The surface was sticky even after repeated cleaning, and a splinter caught the sleeve of my favourite shirt. Whenever I put down a cup, I had to choose its position as carefully as if I were solving a puzzle.
So I repaired it. I fixed the leg, smoothed the dangerous edges and removed the damaged finish. The work erased some shallow scratches and made the candle mark less obvious. For a few days, the table looked strangely formal, as though it were waiting for permission to become part of the room.
Then ordinary life returned. A visitor left a wet glass on it. My daughter pressed too hard while writing and produced the faint outline of a sentence. I was annoyed for approximately ten seconds. After that, I realised the table had not lost its history. It had simply begun another part of it.
Keeping an object does not have to mean freezing it at the moment we receive it. Memories are not stored only in damaged varnish. I can remember my aunt’s kitchen while using a table that no longer catches my clothes or spills my tea. Repairing it was not a rejection of its past. It was how I made room for its future.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about restoring old objects and preserving signs of their previous use.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.