Text One: The page with the correction
A feature by the editor of a student newspaper.
The first bundle arrived from the printer with the wrong room number on the front page. We covered it with red correction stickers, which made the mistake more noticeable rather than less. I spent the morning imagining complaints. By lunchtime, students who had never picked up the paper before were carrying it around and asking who had checked the headline.
That awkward first issue taught me what a school newspaper can be. A noticeboard delivers finished information; a newspaper allows people to answer back. Our review of the school play annoyed two actors, who wrote a response for the next edition. An article about the lunch queue produced three proposed solutions and an argument about whether students or staff should be served first. The paper did not settle either debate. It gave the disagreements somewhere public to exist.
Editing, however, cannot mean printing every sentence we receive. We remove claims that cannot be supported, ask people to distinguish observation from rumour and offer a right of reply when criticism names an individual or group. These decisions sometimes disappoint contributors, but freedom without checking is only noise beneath a masthead. A publication earns trust by showing that its words have been tested.
Our strongest investigation concerned the heating in the art block. The writers collected dates, photographed the classroom thermometer and invited the site manager to explain the delay. The radiators were not repaired immediately, but the school published a schedule for the work and acknowledged that previous messages had been unclear. The article mattered because it replaced corridor speculation with evidence and an answer that readers could examine.
There is still a danger that a school paper becomes a polished advertisement. For that reason, the headteacher reads each issue after the student editors have agreed its contents, not before. If every sentence must make the school appear calm, readers will distrust even the cheerful ones. I would rather publish a disagreement with names beneath it than fill a page with approved enthusiasm that nobody believes.
Text Two: The voices left in the tray
A commentary by a student whose work was submitted to the school newspaper.
During assembly, a teacher held up the latest issue as proof that students were being heard. I recognised the building in its photographs and several friends in the sports pages, but I did not recognise the school we discussed between lessons. The most striking feature of the newspaper was not any headline. It was the absence of subjects that might have disturbed the celebration.
I had submitted a report about a timetable change that left music groups with nowhere suitable to rehearse. It was returned with the comment "too specialised". In the same issue, the front page was given to a team holding a trophy. The achievement deserved attention, but the choice revealed what the paper found easiest to value: a success that fitted one photograph rather than an inconvenience requiring several explanations.
The editors work hard, and eight printed pages cannot contain every opinion. Yet limited space does not make selection neutral. The same confident contributors understand the deadlines, know the preferred tone and are comfortable entering the newspaper office to argue for a paragraph. Whose version of school life appears when those habits become the unofficial entrance test?
Even published voices can be made tidier than they really are. For an article about the new library rules, several students gave sharply different responses. Their comments appeared as four short phrases around a paragraph claiming that the change had received a "mixed but broadly positive" reaction. The wording sounded balanced, but it turned an unresolved argument into a manageable summary. Readers saw the conclusion without seeing who had constructed it.
On the final afternoon of term, I noticed a tray of unused drafts beneath the editors’ desk: poems, letters, reports and reviews, some weak and some excellent. Upstairs, the newest issue stood in a glass case looking complete. A school newspaper may never represent everyone, but it should not mistake a finished layout for the whole school. Its silences deserve as much scrutiny as its headlines.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about school-produced newspapers.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.