Beyond the bag count
Text One: After the cheer
An original personal account by a first-time beach-clean volunteer.
At noon, a cheer went up for thirty-one sacks. I cheered as well, then looked at the tied bags beside the steps and felt unexpectedly doubtful. Was success really the amount of rubbish we had managed to find?
Two hours earlier, I had been given gloves, a litter picker and a section of beach near the benches. From the promenade, the sand had appeared reasonably tidy. At ground level, the job became stubbornly specific: a strip of plastic trapped beneath a seat, damp receipts folded into the pebbles, a bottle top pressed almost level with the path. My bag filled slowly while other volunteers carried away objects large enough to be seen from across the beach.
The organiser assured us that every bag counted. I understood the encouragement, but the total made many different kinds of effort sound identical. One volunteer had dragged an abandoned chair from behind a shelter. Another had spent twenty minutes collecting tiny scraps from a single corner. Both contributions disappeared into the number thirty-one.
A passer-by called, ‘You’ll be doing all this again next week.’ At first, I heard mockery. The woman working beside me simply replied, ‘That’s the point.’ Soon the three of us were discussing overflowing bins, windy days and the smaller group that met twice a month. The interruption became the most useful part of my morning.
When we finished, there was no dramatic transformation. The paths were clearer and the area around the benches was less untidy, but the beach remained recognisably itself. The organiser then read out dates for future clean-ups, without banners or a public count. I added my name to the list.
On the bus home, the new date in my diary mattered more to me than thirty-one. The morning’s result was real, but its greater value might lie in persuading some of us to return.
Text Two: Count the returns
An original opinion column by a coastal resident.
Thirty-one sacks looks excellent in a headline. It gives an untidy problem a tidy ending: volunteers arrived, rubbish vanished and the beach was saved for the year. Those of us who live nearby know that the coast does not follow the shape of a press release.
A large Saturday event concentrates attention. It also concentrates people in the broad stretch of sand nearest the car park. Meanwhile, the narrow path beyond the eastern steps receives fewer volunteers because no banner can be planted there and groups cannot gather comfortably. On Monday morning, a resident will still walk that path with an old bucket, doing work too small to be announced over a loudspeaker.
I do not want the organised clean-up cancelled. It lends equipment to people who do not own any and allows someone to contribute an hour without first joining a committee. Neighbours who have never spoken meet beside the collection point. Several members of our regular group first appeared at one of these larger events.
My objection is to the language of completion. A pile of sacks cannot tell us whether every part of the beach received attention, whether bins will be emptied promptly in future or whether volunteers will return in poor weather. The single triumphant total borrows importance from the quieter months around it.
Organisers could treat the event as a doorway rather than a grand finale. Put the next six dates on every notice. Ask volunteers which areas they could revisit. Celebrate the person who comes back as warmly as the person who fills the largest sack. Public enthusiasm is valuable, but it should be directed beyond one morning.
By all means, count what is collected. Then publish the more revealing figure later: how many volunteers return when nobody is counting?
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about what organised beach clean-ups can achieve.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.