A slice for the judges
Text One: an original account of judging a cake competition.
The cakes arrived looking certain of themselves. One carried a tower of sugar flowers; another had been covered in such smooth icing that it resembled a polished stone. Beside them, a plain round cake waited on a paper plate with its entry number written in pencil.
We were told to judge without knowing who had baked them. This was straightforward until the first slice was cut. A competitor’s cough came from behind us, followed by the sudden silence of somebody trying very hard not to cough again.
My fellow judge, Dev, began with the plain cake. He broke off a small piece, tasted it and wrote something down. I looked at the sugar flowers. They appeared to have required a level of patience which ought to be rewarded before anyone ate anything.
The flowered cake was dry. There was no kind way to discover this, though I spent several seconds chewing as if kindness might alter the result. Dev offered water without comment. We turned to the next plate.
As the tasting continued, the table lost its parade-ground order. Crumbs spread across the cloth. Beautiful surfaces became cut edges; the plain cake revealed a fine, even interior. Our notes grew less concerned with how much work a cake seemed to announce and more concerned with what a slice actually offered.
When the results were read out, the winner came forward with flour still caught in the seam of a sleeve. The plain cake had belonged to her. She looked at the remaining slices before taking the certificate, as though checking that there would be enough to share.
How does the writer explore the difference between appearance and quality?
Support your answer with close reference to the text, including brief quotations.
97 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.