The case for leaving a blank
Text One: an original non-fiction practice text.
A complete form looks reassuring. Every box contains a number, every line ends with an answer, and the person receiving it can turn the page without asking what has been left out. In our recent survey of local footpaths, however, some of the most honest entries were empty.
We had asked volunteers to record the width of each path. Most measurements were straightforward. At several locations, parked vehicles or temporary fencing prevented anyone from reaching both edges. The first version of the spreadsheet required a number in every row. One volunteer entered zero, adding an explanation in a separate message. Another estimated. A third abandoned the form altogether.
None of those responses told us reliably how wide the path was. Zero was a measurement with a meaning of its own; it did not mean “I could not measure this”. An estimate might be useful, but only if a later reader knew it was an estimate. A form that demanded certainty had begun manufacturing it.
We changed the design. Volunteers could mark a measurement as unavailable, give a reason, and upload a photograph. Estimates occupied a separate column. The resulting sheet looked less tidy. It was also possible to tell which paths needed another visit.
There is a temptation to treat a blank as a failure of effort. Sometimes it is exactly that. Sometimes, though, a blank is a boundary drawn around what a person actually knows. If we fill it merely to satisfy a form, we have improved the appearance of our information while weakening the information itself. I would rather receive a question we can investigate than an answer we have taught somebody to invent.
How does the writer use language and structure to persuade the reader that incomplete data can be valuable?
Support your answer with close reference to the text, including brief quotations.
97 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.