The view supplied
Text One: an original travel column about a hilltop viewpoint.
The new platform offers the best view of the valley, according to the sign at the foot of the path. By the time I reached it, I had been told what to admire four times. An arrow identified the river, another the ruined tower, and a metal frame marked the position from which to take the approved photograph.
The valley was beautiful. I should say that before complaining about the arrangements made for seeing it. Fields descended in uneven bands towards the water, and the tower stood beyond a fold in the ground, looking less like a destination than an interruption in the trees.
Inside the frame, everything fitted. A visitor placed a phone on the indicated ledge, stepped back and smiled at a view she could no longer see because she was facing the camera. Behind the next group, a child crouched to examine a beetle. His parent asked him to come and look at something interesting.
I walked a little way along the fence. From there, a warehouse roof entered the picture. So did a line of washing and the traffic on the bridge. These did not improve the photograph. They complicated the valley, giving it things to do besides being looked at.
The platform has useful features. Its level surface allows people to stop safely, and its rail gives tired walkers somewhere to lean. I am not proposing that we dismantle it. I would simply like one sign which stops short of deciding what a visitor must see.
On the descent, the tower disappeared. The sound of the river became clearer, and a sheep leaned over a wall to investigate my sleeve. None of these developments had been announced. I found that I was still enjoying the view.
How does the writer question the way the viewpoint directs visitors’ attention?
Support your answer with close reference to the text, including brief quotations.
97 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.