A drink should not need an assistant
Text One: an original opinion article about proposed public drinking fountains.
At the council’s demonstration, the first person invited to try the new drinking fountain was six-year-old Sami. He reached for the control, missed it and stretched again. His fingers closed on air. An official leaned over and pressed the button; water struck the basin and applause travelled through the crowd. By then, Sami was watching the pigeons.
Only afterwards did we learn that twenty copies of this model could soon be installed across the town. The council calls an identical design “consistent”. But “same” and “fair” are not synonyms. The market square is crowded at lunchtime, the riverside path narrows beside the bridge, and the playground is used by some of the town’s smallest residents. A town is not a page on which one symbol can be stamped twenty times.
Before the metal is ordered, somebody should test the plan with people rather than pins on a map. Can a child operate the control? Can a bottle rest beneath the spout? Is there room for a wheelchair beside it? Where will people stand if a queue forms? These are small questions only in the sense that a key is a small object: each can decide whether something opens.
The online consultation asks residents to rank three colours and place ticks beside a list of already selected sites. It invites us to decorate a decision, not participate in one. We may choose the fountain’s coat, but we are not asked whether it fits.
No single design will suit every person in every circumstance. True. Yet perfection is a false opponent: it allows workable improvements to be dismissed because they are not miracles. Put different controls and heights in two trial locations. Watch how people use them without instructions. Move a fountain if it blocks a path. Planning should be a rehearsal, not a receipt.
Sami’s difficulty was not reluctance, impatience or lack of explanation. The fountain failed the simplest encounter. If success means twenty marks added to a map, the scheme will be easy to declare complete. Judge it instead from a child’s height, bottle by bottle, person by person. The next child should leave with water, not serve as part of the demonstration.
How does the writer use language and structure to persuade the reader that the fountain design should be tested before it is installed across the town?
Support your answer with close reference to the text, including brief quotations.
97 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.