The grant appeal

The chair approached the appeal with an open mind, setting aside her notes from the first meeting before reading the applicant's new evidence. She was meticulous, checking every claim against the dated correspondence and the published funding criteria. Although the panel's schedule was crowded, she refused to hurry the discussion. She also invited the member who disagreed most strongly with her to speak first. The original decision remained unchanged, but every objection received a considered response.

From the passage, select two words or phrases that show what kind of reviewer the chair was.