9.5.1 Rusting and barrier methods
What rusting is
Corrosion
The gradual destruction of a metal as it reacts with substances around it, such as oxygen and water.
Rusting
The corrosion of iron or steel by reaction with oxygen and water to form hydrated iron(III) oxide.
- Rust is hydrated iron(III) oxide, an orange-brown, crumbly solid.
- Only iron and steel rust, because steel is mostly iron, so the corrosion of other metals is not called rusting.
- The word equation is iron+oxygen+water→hydrated iron(III) oxide\text{iron} + \text{oxygen} + \text{water} \rightarrow \text{hydrated iron(III) oxide}iron+oxygen+water→hydrated iron(III) oxide.
- Iron gains oxygen as it rusts, so rusting is an oxidation reaction.
- Rust is weak and flakes away from the surface, which exposes fresh iron underneath to further rusting.
- Left unprotected, rusting continues until the iron is eaten right through, which weakens car bodies, bridges, ships and railings.
Conditions for rusting
- Iron and steel rust only when both oxygen and water are present at the surface of the metal.
- The oxygen comes from the air, or from air that has dissolved in the water.
- If either oxygen or water is missing, rusting does not happen.
- Iron rusts faster in salty water, which is why cars on gritted winter roads and ships at sea rust quickly.
Finding the conditions needed for rusting
- Aim: to find out whether both oxygen and water are needed for iron to rust.
- Apparatus: four boiling tubes in a rack, four clean iron nails, emery paper, tap water, distilled water that has just been boiled, a little cooking oil, salt solution, anhydrous calcium chloride, cotton wool, a bung and labels.
- Method, setting up:
- Rub each nail with emery paper so that all four start with a clean, shiny surface.
- Tube A, oxygen and water: stand a nail in tap water and leave the tube open to the air.
- Tube B, water but no oxygen: stand a nail in freshly boiled distilled water, which has had its dissolved air driven out, and pour a layer of oil on top to stop air dissolving back in.
- Tube C, oxygen but no water: put anhydrous calcium chloride in the bottom of the tube, cover it with a plug of cotton wool, rest the nail on top and seal the tube with a bung.
- Tube D, oxygen and salty water: stand a nail in salt solution and leave the tube open to the air.
- Method, observing:
- Leave the four tubes in the rack at room temperature for about a week.
- Compare the amount of orange-brown rust on each nail and record your observations in a table.
- Results: the nail in tube A rusts, the nails in tubes B and C stay shiny, and the nail in tube D is the most heavily rusted.
- Conclusion: iron rusts only when oxygen and water are both present, and dissolved salt speeds up rusting.
- Watch out: add the oil to tube B as soon as the boiled water has cooled, because air starts to dissolve back into the water straight away, and keep tube C sealed so that the calcium chloride can keep the air inside dry.
- Safety: wear eye protection, take care with the boiling water, and wash your hands after handling anhydrous calcium chloride, which irritates the skin.
Barrier methods
Barrier method
A way of preventing rusting by covering iron or steel with a layer that stops oxygen and water from reaching the metal.
- Barrier methods prevent rusting by excluding oxygen and water from the surface of the iron or steel.
- Painting
- A coat of paint seals the surface of large objects such as bridges, ships, car bodies and railings.
- Paint must be renewed from time to time, because it chips and flakes.
- Greasing or oiling
- A layer of grease or oil protects moving parts, such as bicycle chains, hinges and machine gears, where paint would be scraped off.
- The grease also lubricates the parts, but it wears away and must be reapplied.
- Coating with plastic
- A tough plastic layer protects objects such as garden furniture, wire fences, dish racks and fridge shelves.
- A plastic coating needs no repainting, but it can split or tear.
- A barrier method only works while the coating is unbroken.
- If the barrier is scratched or chipped, oxygen and water reach the bare iron, and rusting starts at that point.
- Rust can then spread underneath the surrounding paint and lift it away from the metal.
Choosing a barrier method
- A bicycle chain has moving parts that rub together, so paint would soon wear off, and greasing is used instead because it keeps out oxygen and water while also lubricating the chain.
- A steel bridge is huge and fixed in place, so painting is the most practical way to seal its whole surface.
- A wire garden fence is coated with plastic, because the coating is tough, lasts for years and never needs repainting.
Explaining how a method prevents rusting
- State what the coating does, writing that it stops oxygen and water reaching the iron, because naming the method alone, such as "it is painted", does not explain it.
- When asked for the conditions for rusting, give oxygen and water together, because one of them alone does not earn the mark.
- When asked to choose a method, link it to the object, so moving parts are greased while large fixed structures are painted.
- Do not describe rust simply as iron oxide, because it is hydrated iron(III) oxide.
- Do not say that rusting needs only air or only water, because both oxygen and water are needed.
- Do not use the word rusting for other metals, because aluminium and zinc corrode but only iron and steel rust.
- What is the chemical name for rust?
- Which two substances must be present for iron to rust?
- Why is the water in tube B boiled and then covered with oil?
- Name three barrier methods.
- How does a barrier method prevent rusting?
9.5.2 Galvanising and sacrificial protection
Galvanising
Galvanising
Coating iron or steel with a layer of zinc to protect it from rusting.
- Steel is galvanised by dipping it into a bath of molten zinc, which leaves a thin, even coating of zinc over the whole surface.
- Galvanised steel is used for objects that stand outdoors for years, such as roofing sheets, fences, lamp posts, crash barriers and buckets.
- The zinc coating acts as a barrier method, because it stops oxygen and water from reaching the steel underneath.
- The zinc itself reacts slowly with the air to form a dull, protective surface layer, so the coating lasts a long time.
- Unlike paint, a zinc coating carries on protecting the steel even after it has been scratched, because zinc also gives sacrificial protection.
Sacrificial protection
Sacrificial protection
The protection of iron from rusting by a more reactive metal in contact with it, which loses electrons and corrodes in place of the iron.
Oxidation
The loss of electrons by a substance.
- Zinc is above iron in the reactivity series, so zinc is more reactive than iron.
- A more reactive metal has a greater tendency to lose electrons and form positive ions.
- When a galvanised surface is scratched, oxygen and water reach the bare iron, but the zinc around the scratch loses electrons in preference to the iron: Zn(s)→Zn2+(aq)+2e−\mathrm{Zn(s) \rightarrow Zn^{2+}(aq) + 2e^-}Zn(s)→Zn2+(aq)+2e−.
- The zinc is oxidised and slowly corrodes away, which is why it is described as being sacrificed.
- The electrons released by the zinc pass into the iron, so the iron does not lose its own electrons.
- The iron is not oxidised to iron ions, so it does not rust.
- The protection lasts only as long as some zinc remains in contact with the iron.
- Any metal more reactive than iron can give sacrificial protection, and magnesium is often used as well as zinc.
- Blocks of zinc or magnesium are bolted onto the steel hulls of ships, oil rigs and underground pipelines.
- The blocks corrode instead of the steel and are replaced when they have worn away.
- A less reactive metal such as copper cannot protect iron in this way, because iron loses electrons more readily than copper does.
Testing sacrificial protection
- Aim: to show that a more reactive metal in contact with iron stops it rusting, while a less reactive metal does not.
- Apparatus: four iron nails, a strip of magnesium ribbon, a strip of zinc foil, a strip of copper foil, emery paper, four test tubes in a rack, sodium chloride solution and labels.
- Method, setting up:
- Rub each nail and each metal strip with emery paper until it is shiny.
- Wrap the magnesium ribbon tightly around the first nail, the zinc foil around the second and the copper foil around the third, so that each metal presses firmly against the iron.
- Leave the fourth nail bare as a control.
- Stand each nail in its own labelled tube and cover it with salt solution, which speeds up rusting, leaving the tubes open to the air.
- Method, observing:
- Leave the tubes for four to five days.
- Compare the amount of orange-brown rust on each nail and the appearance of each wrapping metal.
- Results: the nails wrapped in magnesium and zinc show no rust while the magnesium and zinc look dull and pitted, the bare nail rusts, and the nail wrapped in copper rusts even more than the bare nail.
- Conclusion: magnesium and zinc are more reactive than iron, so they lose electrons and corrode instead of the iron, but copper is less reactive and gives no protection.
- Watch out: the wrapping metal must stay in firm contact with the nail, because sacrificial protection works only when the two metals touch.
- Safety: wear eye protection, and wash your hands after handling the corroded metals and the salt solution.
Barrier and sacrificial protection compared
- Barrier protection works only while the coating is complete, so painted steel starts to rust as soon as the paint is chipped.
- Sacrificial protection still works when the surface is damaged, because the more reactive metal corrodes instead of the exposed iron.
- Galvanising gives both kinds of protection at once, which is why galvanised steel lasts far longer outdoors than painted steel.
Protecting a steel ship
- A steel hull is painted to give barrier protection.
- Blocks of zinc are also bolted to the hull below the waterline.
- Where the paint is damaged, zinc loses electrons more readily than iron, so the zinc corrodes and the exposed steel does not rust.
- The zinc blocks are replaced in dry dock once they have corroded away.
Explaining sacrificial protection
- Mark schemes look for two ideas: zinc is more reactive than iron, and zinc loses electrons or is oxidised in preference to iron.
- Use the phrase in preference to or instead of, so that it is clear the zinc reacts and the iron does not.
- For a question on galvanising with enough marks, describe both the barrier effect and the sacrificial effect.
- Write the oxidation half-equation for zinc with the electrons on the right-hand side.
- Do not say that zinc is less reactive than iron, because a sacrificial metal must be more reactive than iron.
- Do not say that sacrificial protection works by keeping out oxygen and water, because that is the barrier effect.
- Do not say that the iron loses electrons to the zinc, because electrons flow from the zinc to the iron.
- What is galvanising?
- How does a zinc coating act as a barrier?
- Why does zinc protect iron even when the coating is scratched?
- Write the half-equation for the oxidation of zinc.
- Why can copper not be used to give sacrificial protection to iron?