What trait theory claims
- Trait theory explains personality as a set of stable characteristics that a person carries from one situation into the next.
- Allport (1936) set out what kinds of trait exist and how much of a person each kind accounts for.
- Cattell (1946) built a questionnaire that turns traits into scores, producing a profile of a whole personality.
Trait
A relatively stable characteristic that describes how a person tends to think, feel and behave across time.
Allport's three kinds of trait
- Cardinal traits
- A cardinal trait is a single characteristic so dominant that nearly everything the person does can be traced back to it.
- Allport regarded cardinal traits as rare, because most people are not organised around one overriding quality.
- Central traits
- Central traits are the small handful of characteristics that together describe most of an ordinary personality.
- They are the words you would reach for if you had to sum someone up, such as honest, anxious, generous or determined.
- Secondary traits
- Secondary traits appear only in particular situations, so they are less consistent and less obvious to other people.
- Getting impatient in queues, or going quiet in large groups, sits at this level rather than at the central one.
- A reference written for a friend might call her reliable and warm, which are central traits.
- Adding that she dislikes speaking in front of a class describes a secondary trait, because it applies to one setting.
- Only if every choice she made served one overriding quality would you be describing a cardinal trait.
Cattell's 16PF
- Cattell started from the very large number of words people use to describe each other and looked for the pattern underneath them.
- He gathered ratings of people and used a statistical technique, factor analysis, which finds out which descriptions tend to rise and fall together.
- The visible descriptions are surface traits, while the deeper characteristics they point to are source traits.
- The analysis reduced that mass of descriptions to 16 source traits, and those 16 are what the name 16PF refers to.
- The 16PF itself is a questionnaire, and your answers to its items are scored on each of the 16 factors.
- Each factor runs between two opposite poles, such as reserved at one end and outgoing at the other, so your score places you somewhere between them.
- The 16 scores are then plotted together as a personality profile, so a whole personality is described by a pattern of scores rather than by a single label.
Strengths of trait theory
- A strength is that it is measurable, so personality can be studied with numbers instead of impressions, and findings can be checked and repeated by other researchers.
- A second strength is that it has real uses, because questionnaires of this kind are used in settings such as job selection and careers guidance.
Weaknesses of trait theory
- A weakness is that it describes personality without explaining it, because knowing that someone scores highly on a trait says nothing about where that trait came from.
- A second weakness is that traits predict behaviour imperfectly, since the same person acts differently depending on the situation they are in.
- Do not write that trait theory explains why a person has their traits, because it sets out to describe and measure them.
- Do not swap the three kinds over, since cardinal dominates a whole life, central is core and everyday, and secondary is tied to particular situations.
- Do not treat a high or low score on a factor as a good or bad personality, because a profile records differences and not merit.
Turning this into marks
- Name Allport's cardinal, central and secondary traits, and Cattell's 16 source traits measured by the 16PF.
- Attach a short example to each kind of trait.
- The mark most often lost is saying that a weakness exists without saying why it matters for using the theory.
- What is a cardinal trait, and why did Allport treat it as rare?
- Which of Allport's three kinds would "goes quiet in large groups" be?
- What does the 16 in 16PF stand for?
- How does the 16PF turn a personality into a profile?
- Give one strength and one weakness of trait theory, and say why each one matters.