Aims
CBT
Cognitive behaviour therapy, a talking therapy that helps a person identify and change the unhelpful thoughts that drive their distress, so that their behaviour and feelings can change too.
- To find out how effective CBT is as a treatment for internet addiction.
- To see whether clients could manage the thoughts and behaviours behind compulsive internet use and hold on to that change afterwards.
Procedure
- There were 114 clients at the Center for Online Addiction in Pennsylvania, 42 per cent of them women.
- Most were Caucasian at 84%, 61% held bachelor's degrees, and the mean age was 38 for the men and 46 for the women.
- Clients were screened with the Internet Addiction Test, and high-risk cases were excluded.
- Clients rated their own progress on a client outcome questionnaire of 12 items, each scored on a 5-point scale.
- It was completed at sessions 3, 8 and 12, and once more at a 6-month follow-up.
Results
- The problems clients reported most often were time (96%) and relationship (85%), then sexual problems at 75% and work problems at 71%.
- Below those came financial problems at 42%, physical problems at 29% and academic problems at 15%.
- Most clients showed continuous improvement by session 3 and effective symptom management by sessions 8 and 12.
- Those gains were maintained at the 6-month follow-up, and relapse prevention was achieved by clients over that period too.
Conclusions
- Young concluded that CBT reduced the compulsive-use thoughts and behaviours that had brought clients into treatment.
- CBT also supported relapse prevention, since the improvement was still there six months after treatment.
Strengths and weaknesses
- A strength is that these were real clients receiving real treatment in a clinic, which gives the study high ecological validity.
- A second strength is that the 6-month follow-up shows the change lasted rather than fading once the sessions stopped.
- A weakness is that there was no control group, so the improvement cannot be attributed to the CBT rather than to time passing.
- A second weakness is that the outcomes were entirely self-reported, which invites social desirability from clients who want to please their therapist.
Turning this into marks
- State a precise result, so 96% reported problems with time is safer than most clients had problems.
- Name the 114 clients, the Internet Addiction Test screening and the measurements at sessions 3, 8 and 12.
- Weigh the ecological validity against the missing control group rather than simply listing both.
- How many clients took part, and where were they being treated?
- At which four points was the outcome questionnaire completed?
- How many items did the outcome questionnaire have, and what scale was used?
- Which problem did the largest percentage of clients report, and what was that percentage?
- Why does the absence of a control group limit what Young can conclude?