Skip to content

Course home

Sign up

11.1.2 Controlling extraneous variables

What a control is for

  1. A control is a step you build into the way you run a study so that an extraneous variable cannot move your results.
  2. The target is a fair comparison in which the conditions differ in the independent variable and in nothing else.

Standardised procedures

Definition

Standardisation

Keeping the procedure, instructions and conditions exactly the same for every participant so that everyone is treated in the same way.

  1. A standardised procedure is a fixed set of steps, instructions, materials and timings used with every single participant.
  2. You write the instructions out word for word, run every session in the same kind of room and give everyone the same amount of time.
  3. The problem it solves is situational variables drifting from one participant to the next, so the setting cannot be the reason one group scored higher.

Counterbalancing

Definition

Counterbalancing

A technique for controlling order effects in a repeated measures design, where the order in which participants do the conditions is varied so that half do them one way round and half the other.

  1. Counterbalancing means splitting your participants in half and having each half do the two conditions in the opposite order.
  2. The problem it solves is order effects, which appear when everyone takes part in both conditions and doing one first changes how they do the second.
    1. People may get better through practice or worse through boredom and tiredness, and either way the order rather than the independent variable would be shifting the scores.
  3. Counterbalancing does not remove those effects, it spreads them evenly across both conditions so that they cancel out.
Example
  • Fifteen students do the silent memory task first and the noisy one second, while the other fifteen do the noisy one first.
  • If practice helps, it now helps the silent condition and the noisy condition equally.

Randomisation

Definition

Randomisation

Using chance, such as drawing names or a random number list, to decide things like the order of tasks or how participants are allocated, reducing the researcher's influence.

  1. Randomisation means letting chance, rather than your own judgement, decide something about how the study is run.
  2. You can randomise the order of the items in a task, the order the materials are presented in, or which condition each participant takes part in.
  3. The problem it solves is your own preferences quietly shaping the study, such as putting the keenest students into the condition you hope will win.
  4. When chance decides who goes into each condition, participant variables such as ability and motivation are more likely to spread evenly than to pile up in one group.

Single-blind techniques

  1. In a single-blind technique the participants are not told which condition they are in or what the study expects to find.
  2. The problem it solves is participants working out the aim and then behaving in the way they think is wanted, which is known as demand characteristics.
  3. With nothing to guess from, they have no way of helping the prediction along and behave more naturally.

Double-blind techniques

  1. In a double-blind technique neither the participants nor the person running the session knows which condition is which.
  2. The problem it solves is the researcher giving away what they expect, through tone of voice, extra encouragement or the way they mark an answer that could go either way.
  3. It therefore holds down the expectations of the participants and of the researcher at the same time, which makes it the stronger of the two techniques.
Common Mistake
  • Do not list controls without saying which problem each one deals with.
  • Do not offer counterbalancing when each participant takes part in only one condition, because there is no order to balance.
  • Do not claim that a single-blind technique controls participant variables, because it does nothing about who ends up in each group.

Turning this into marks

  1. Name the control and say what it stops in that particular study.
  2. Write the control in the words of the scenario, such as reading the same instructions to both Year 9 classes.
  3. The mark most often lost comes from defining a control in general terms without applying it to the study in front of you.
Self review
  • Which control deals with order effects, and how does it work?
  • What is the difference between a single-blind and a double-blind technique?
  • Which control would you use if you were worried about the strongest readers all ending up in one condition?
  • Give two things you would keep identical in a standardised procedure.
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 11.1.2 Controlling extraneous variables by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

9 minute activity

Start lesson

A control is a step built into a study to limit the influence of an extraneous variable on the results. An extraneous variable is anything other than the independent variable that could affect the dependent variable.

The aim is for conditions to differ only in the independent variable. For example, when comparing memory in silence and noise, giving the silent group more learning time would make the comparison unfair.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

23 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What is the purpose of building a control into a study?

11.1.2 Controlling extraneous variables Revision Guide

  1. GCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /11.1.2 Controlling extraneous variables

Revision notes for Edexcel GCSE Psychology 11.1.2 Controlling extraneous variables: explanations and worked examples.

Revision guides