This article covers 3.2.2 Language, thought and communication of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Piaget: Thought Comes First, Words Follow
- Piaget claimed that language depends on thought, so your thinking has to develop before your words can.
- Cognitive development drives language, which means it comes first and language follows behind it.
- A child builds up an idea, or schema, of something in the world before any word is attached to it.
- You can only use a word meaningfully once you already grasp the concept it stands for.
- For Piaget, language is just one way a child shows the thinking that is already there.
Key Idea
- Thinking shapes language, not the other way round.
- The concept has to exist in the mind before the word can mean anything.
Pre-Linguistic Thought
- Long before you could speak, you were already thinking.
- A baby forms ideas about the world through its senses and its actions, such as grabbing, dropping and watching.
- One clear sign of this is object permanence: knowing something still exists even when you cannot see it.
- A baby shows object permanence by reaching for a hidden toy well before it can say the toy's name.
- So the idea arrives first, and the word is simply attached to an idea the child already holds.
Example
- Hide your keys under a tea towel in front of a one-year-old and they will lift the towel to find them, even with no word for keys yet.
- They understand the keys are still there, and only months later learn to call them keys.
- Think of it like a toolbox: you learn what each tool does first, then later stick a label on it.
Strengths and Weaknesses
- Strength
- It fits real evidence that babies can think before they can talk, such as showing object permanence without any words.
- It also explains why simply telling a child a concept does not work until they are cognitively ready for it.
- Weakness
- It cannot explain cases where language seems to shape thought, which is exactly what the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis claims.
- Critics argue that language can push cognitive development forward, not just trail behind it.
Common Mistake
- Do not say Piaget thought language and thought were the same thing.
- His whole point is that they are separate, and that thought clearly leads.
Answering a Question on Piaget's View
- Make the direction of cause clear from the start: thought comes first, language follows.
- Bring in pre-linguistic thought as your key term, and back it with the object permanence example.
- The mark most people drop is the evaluation, so always name a competing view like the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis rather than just describing.
Self review
- In Piaget's view, does thought or language develop first?
- What is pre-linguistic thought?
- How does object permanence support Piaget's theory?
- Give one weakness of Piaget's view that language depends on thought.