This article covers 3.1.4 Research methods of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Ethical Issues: Protecting the People Who Take Part
- Ethical issues are the ways a study could harm or wrong the people who take part in it.
- In the UK the British Psychological Society (BPS) sets the guidelines that psychologists follow.
- In the exam you name the issue a study raises and point to exactly what raises it.
Key Idea
- Ethics is about the welfare and rights of participants, not the neatness of the results.
- Every issue below is one you must be able to spot in a described study.
Informed Consent
- Participants should agree to take part knowing what the study involves and any risks.
- For under-16s a parent or guardian must give consent on their behalf.
- Without this, people cannot make a free, genuine choice about joining.
Deception
- Deception means deliberately misleading participants or hiding the true aim.
- It blocks informed consent, because you cannot agree to something you were never told about.
- Mild deception is sometimes allowed when a study could not work otherwise, but it must be justified and participants should be debriefed at the end of the study.
Protection from Harm
- Participants should not face physical or psychological harm, such as stress, embarrassment or fear.
- They should leave in no worse a state than when they arrived.
Right to Withdraw
- Participants can stop and leave at any time, without giving a reason.
- They can also ask for their data to be removed afterwards.
Confidentiality and Privacy
- Confidentiality means keeping personal data and identity private, so results cannot be traced to a person.
- Privacy is slightly different: it means not intruding on people in situations where they expect to be unobserved.
- Using code numbers or false names instead of real names protects confidentiality.
Example
- A psychologist secretly films shoppers in a Cardiff supermarket to record helping behaviour.
- The shoppers never agreed to take part, so there is no informed consent.
- They are recorded in a place where they expect not to be studied, which invades their privacy.
- If the footage shows recognisable faces alongside names, confidentiality is broken too.
Spotting Ethical Issues in a Described Study
- Ask whether participants knew what they were agreeing to.
- Ask whether they were misled, distressed, unable to leave or identifiable.
- Name each issue and point to exactly what in the study raises it.
Dealing With Ethical Issues
- Each ethical issue has a set technique that reduces or removes it.
- These techniques are set out in a code of conduct that all UK psychologists must follow.
- The aim is to protect participants without wrecking the study.
Key Idea
- To answer well, match the issue to the technique that deals with it, then say how the participant is protected.
- A fix that does not match the issue earns nothing.
The Fixes That Match Each Issue
- For consent: explain the study and gain informed consent before it begins, and for a child get their assent plus a parent's consent.
- For deception: debrief participants afterwards, revealing the true aim and any deception used.
- For the right to withdraw: tell participants at the start they may leave at any time and have their data removed.
- For confidentiality: store data securely and use code numbers, not real names, in the results.
When You Cannot Ask First: Consent Workarounds
- If telling people the aim would ruin the study, presumptive consent asks a similar group whether they would agree.
- Prior general consent, where people agree in advance that they may be deceived in some studies, is another option.
- Neither fully replaces real informed consent, so a proper debrief afterwards still matters.
Example
- You want to test whether pupils conform to a group's wrong answer, so you cannot reveal the real aim in advance.
- You gain presumptive consent from a similar Year 10 class first, who agree the study sounds acceptable.
- Afterwards you debrief the real participants, explaining the deception and checking they are not upset.
- You store their responses under code numbers so no answer can be traced to a named pupil.
The Code of Conduct That Governs It All
- UK psychologists must follow the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct, which turns these principles into rules.
- It is built on four principles: respect, competence, responsibility and integrity.
Ethics Committees
Definition
Ethics committee
A panel that reviews a proposed study before it runs, weighing its likely benefits against the risks to participants and deciding whether it may go ahead.
- Before a study runs, an ethics committee reviews the plan and can refuse it or ask for changes.
- This check happens in advance, not after harm has already been done.
Cost-Benefit Analysis
- The committee weighs the study's likely benefits, such as new knowledge, against its costs to participants.
- If the costs outweigh the benefits, the study should not go ahead.
Common Mistake
- Do not offer a fix that does not match the issue, such as a debrief for confidentiality.
- Do not forget that a debrief happens after the study, not before it.
- Do not claim presumptive consent is the same as informed consent; it is a weaker substitute.
Resolving Issues in a Described Study
- Identify the ethical issue the study raises.
- Match it to the technique that deals with it.
- Say how that technique protects the participant.
Self review
- Name three ethical issues in psychological research.
- Which body sets the ethical guidelines UK psychologists follow?
- How does a researcher deal with deception?
- What does the right to withdraw give a participant?
- What does an ethics committee do before a study runs?