This article covers 3.1.3 Development of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Willingham: Memory Is the Residue of Thought
- Willingham, a cognitive scientist, rejects the idea that pupils should be taught according to a learning style, meaning a supposed preferred way of taking in information.
- He argues that what really drives learning is meaning and prior knowledge, not the sense you use to take information in.
- His central slogan is that memory is the residue of thought, so you remember whatever you spend time thinking about.
Key Idea
- Whatever a lesson makes a pupil think about is what they will remember afterwards.
- So the aim of teaching is to direct thought towards the meaning, not towards flashy but empty activity.
The Critique of Learning Styles
- Willingham points out there is no reliable evidence that matching teaching to a pupil's style improves how much they learn.
- What helps is the mode that best fits the content, and that is the same for everyone in the room.
- Labelling a child as a certain type of learner can even hold them back, because it limits the range of teaching they are offered.
Example
- Learning the rivers of the UK, a map helps every pupil because the content is spatial, not because some pupils are visualisers.
- A poem, by contrast, is best heard aloud by everyone, because its rhythm and sound are part of its meaning.
Meaning and Prior Knowledge
- Because memory follows thought, a task that makes pupils think about meaning leaves them remembering the meaning.
- Prior knowledge matters because a new idea only makes sense when it can attach to an existing schema.
- The more you already know, the easier it is to learn more, so gaps in background knowledge tend to widen over time.
- This is why Willingham says teaching should build rich background knowledge and set tasks that force thought about meaning.
Note
- Think of prior knowledge as pegs on a wall: the more pegs you already have, the more new coats of information you can hang up and find again.
Evaluating Willingham
- His theory is strongly backed by cognitive science and memory research, which gives it firm scientific support.
- It is also practical, since teachers can act on it by planning for meaning and building knowledge step by step.
- But critics argue a heavy focus on facts can crowd out skills such as creativity and independent enquiry.
- Deciding whose core knowledge counts also raises fairness questions, and the theory can seem to play down individual differences.
Common Mistake
- Do not write that Willingham proves styles do not exist; his point is that matching teaching to them does not help.
- Do not confuse building background knowledge with mindless rote memorising; the point is thinking about meaning.
Explaining the Theory in an Answer
- State that Willingham rejects matching teaching to learning styles.
- Explain that memory is the residue of thought and why prior knowledge matters.
- Finish with one criticism of the theory.
Self review
- What does Willingham say about learning styles?
- What does 'memory is the residue of thought' mean?
- Why is prior knowledge so important for learning?
- Give one criticism of Willingham's theory.