This article covers 3.1.1 Memory of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
War of the Ghosts: Your Culture Rewrites an Unfamiliar Story
- Bartlett used a Native American folk tale called The War of the Ghosts, which felt strange to his British readers.
- It is the key study behind reconstructive memory, the idea that you rebuild a memory rather than replay it.
- It shows that your schemas, the ready-made packages of prior knowledge you carry, do not just fade a memory but actively rewrite it.
Key Idea
- Because the tale did not fit British schemas, the readers reshaped it to make sense.
- The changes were systematic, pulling in the same cultural direction across different people.
Aim
To investigate how memory changes when people try to recall an unfamiliar story over time.
Method
Definition
Serial reproduction
A technique in which material is recalled and retold repeatedly, so researchers can track how it becomes distorted with each retelling.
- British participants read the unfamiliar tale twice.
- They then recalled it repeatedly over increasing gaps of time, a method Bartlett called serial reproduction.
- Each version they produced was compared with the original story to see what had changed.
Example
- Unfamiliar details such as 'canoes' were recalled as familiar 'boats'.
- 'Hunting seals' drifted towards the more familiar 'fishing'.
- Each swap pulled the tale towards a British schema.
Findings
- The story got steadily shorter with each retelling.
- Strange or supernatural details, like the ghosts, were dropped or rationalised into something more ordinary.
- The distortions were systematic, always shifting the tale towards the participants' own culture.
- Bartlett concluded that recall is an active reconstruction built using schemas, not a faithful copy.
Common Mistake
- Do not say the participants simply forgot bits of the story; the point is that they reshaped it.
- Always name the direction of change: towards the participants' own culture.
Evaluation
- Strength: real-world relevance
- It helps explain why eyewitness accounts are often unreliable, since witnesses reconstruct events using their own schemas.
- Weakness: little control
- Recall was not tested under standardised conditions, so it is hard to be sure the changes were caused by schemas alone.
- Weakness: biased sample
- Participants were a narrow group of British university students, so you cannot safely generalise the findings to other cultures.
- Weakness: subjective scoring
- Bartlett judged the distortions himself without a fixed scoring system, which lowers the reliability of the results.
Self review
- What material did Bartlett use, and why was it chosen?
- What is serial reproduction?
- In which direction did the recalled story change, and why?
- Give one strength and one weakness of the study, including a point about the sample.