This article covers 3.1.1 Memory of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Murdock (1962): Free Recall Gives a U-Shaped Serial Position Curve
Definition
Serial position effect
The finding that a word's position in a list affects how well it is recalled: words at the start (primacy) and end (recency) are remembered better than those in the middle.
- Murdock (1962) is the classic demonstration of the serial position effect.
- Its results are used as evidence that short-term and long-term memory are separate stores.
Key Idea
- The study tests how well a word is recalled depending on where it sat in the list.
- The U-shaped curve, high at both ends and low in the middle, is the result to remember.
Aim: Does a Word's Position Change How Well You Recall It?
- To find out whether a word's position in a list affects the chance you recall it.
- To test whether short-term and long-term memory behave differently within one task.
Method: Hear a Long Word List, Then Recall It Freely
- In a controlled lab experiment, participants heard lists of words read out one at a time, at a steady rate of about one word every one to two seconds.
- The lists varied in length, and the words were unconnected so that meaning could not help recall.
- As soon as a list finished, participants wrote down as many words as they could in any order, which is called free recall.
- Recall was averaged over many lists and people, and the chance of recalling a word was plotted against its position in the list.
Example
- Picture your form tutor reading out a register of twenty names, then asking you to scribble down everyone you can remember in any order.
- That is free recall, and it lets a word's position, not the order you answer in, be studied.
Findings: Best at the Start and End, Worst in the Middle
- Words at the start and end of the list were recalled best, giving a clear U-shaped curve.
- The raised start is the primacy effect and the raised end is the recency effect, while the middle words were recalled worst.
- Murdock read this as two stores at work: the first words had been repeated over and moved into long-term memory, while the last few were still held in short-term memory.
- Later studies back this up, because if you delay recall with a short distractor task the recency effect disappears but primacy stays, exactly what you would expect if recency depends on fragile short-term memory.
Common Mistake
- Do not describe the result as a straight line or a single peak; it is a U-shaped curve with two raised ends.
- Do not stop at the shape, because the marks come from linking the two ends to the two separate stores.
Evaluation: Strong Lab Evidence for Two Stores, but an Artificial Task
- Controlled and replicable
- The lists, timing and free-recall instruction were standardised, so the same U-shaped curve reappears when the study is rerun.
- That consistency makes the finding reliable.
- Strong support for two stores
- The two effects map neatly onto the multi-store model's separate stores.
- Delayed-recall studies reinforce this, because a filler task wipes out recency but leaves primacy.
- Low ecological validity
- Memorising a list of unconnected words is artificial, unlike the meaningful information you usually remember in real life.
- The curve may therefore not reflect how your everyday memory works.
- Narrow sample
- These experiments were often run on small groups of students, so the results may not generalise to older adults or young children.
Self review
- What was the aim of Murdock (1962)?
- What did participants do in the method, and what does free recall mean?
- What shape is the serial position curve, and what are its two effects called?
- Give one strength and one weakness of the study.