Why cables warm up
- Every connecting lead and every mains cable is made of metal, and every metal has some resistance, so charge passing along a cable always leaves a little energy behind in the cable itself.
- That energy is transferred by the drifting electrons colliding with the vibrating ions of the metal, and it ends up in the thermal store of the cable and then of the surroundings.
- Energy dissipated in a cable is wasted twice over. It never reaches the appliance, and it raises the temperature of the cable, which can damage the cable's covering.
- Cable design therefore aims to make the energy dissipated in the cable as small as is reasonably possible, and there are four separate levers available: the metal chosen, the thickness of the wire, the length of the wire, and the size of the current it carries.
- The first three levers all work by lowering the resistance of the wire. The fourth works by reducing how much charge is pushed through that resistance every second.
- None of the four levers can remove the heating completely. A real cable always dissipates some energy, and the target is to make that amount small enough to ignore.
Choosing the metal
Definition
Electrical conductor
An electrical conductor is a material containing charges that are free to move, so it allows a current to flow through it.
- A good electrical conductor holds a very large number of delocalised electrons that are free to move, so a small potential difference is enough to drive a large current through it.
- Copper is the standard choice for connecting leads and mains cables. It has a very low resistance for its size, it can be drawn into thin flexible strands, and it does not corrode quickly.
- Silver is a slightly better conductor than copper, but it is far too expensive to use for ordinary wiring, so it appears only in specialised contacts.
- Iron and steel have a much higher resistance than copper of the same length and thickness, so an iron lead dissipates far more energy for the same current in it.
- Nichrome has a deliberately high resistance and is used for heating elements, which makes it precisely the wrong metal for a connecting lead.
- Aluminium is a poorer conductor than copper but much less dense, so it is chosen where the mass of the cable matters more than the last part of its resistance.
- Changing the metal lowers the resistance without changing the size or shape of the cable at all, which is why it is usually the first design decision made.
Example
Comparing two leads
- A copper lead of length 2.0 m2.0\ \text{m}2.0 m has a resistance of 0.030 Ω0.030\ \Omega0.030 Ω, and an iron lead of the same length and thickness has a resistance of 0.18 Ω0.18\ \Omega0.18 Ω.
- Each lead in turn carries the same current of 5.0 A5.0\ \text{A}5.0 A to the same appliance.
- At a fixed current, the energy dissipated in a lead each second is proportional to the resistance of the lead.
- The ratio of the two resistances is 0.180.030=6.0\dfrac{0.18}{0.030}=6.00.0300.18=6.0.
- The iron lead dissipates six times as much energy each second as the copper lead, which is why copper is used.
Thickness and length
- The cross-sectional area of a wire is the area of the circular face that would be exposed if the wire were cut straight across.
- A wire of larger cross-sectional area has a lower resistance, because the drifting electrons have a wider channel and more routes past the lattice ions, so a smaller fraction of them is obstructed.
- For the same metal and the same length, resistance is inversely proportional to cross-sectional area, so doubling the area halves the resistance.
- A longer wire has a higher resistance, because each electron must pass a greater number of vibrating lattice ions on its way through and so makes more collisions.
- For the same metal and the same thickness, resistance is directly proportional to length, so a 4.0 m4.0\ \text{m}4.0 m lead has twice the resistance of a 2.0 m2.0\ \text{m}2.0 m lead cut from the same reel.
- Halving the resistance of a cable halves the energy dissipated in it each second, provided the current through it is unchanged.
- This is why the flex on a kettle is short and made of thick multi-strand copper, while the hair-thin tracks inside a piece of electronics are acceptable only because the currents in them are tiny.
- Thickness and length cannot be pushed as far as a designer might like. Thick cable costs more, uses more copper and bends less easily, and a cable must be long enough to reach the socket.
Example
Doubling the thickness
- A copper wire of length 3.0 m3.0\ \text{m}3.0 m and cross-sectional area 1.0 mm21.0\ \text{mm}^{2}1.0 mm2 has a resistance of 0.052 Ω0.052\ \Omega0.052 Ω.
- It is replaced by a wire of the same metal and the same length but of cross-sectional area 2.0 mm22.0\ \text{mm}^{2}2.0 mm2.
- Resistance is inversely proportional to cross-sectional area, so the area has doubled and the resistance is halved.
- The new resistance is 0.0522=0.026 Ω\dfrac{0.052}{2}=0.026\ \Omega20.052=0.026 Ω.
- At the same current, halving the resistance halves the energy dissipated in the wire each second.
Keeping the current small
- The energy dissipated in a cable rises steeply as the current in it rises, because a larger current means more charge passing every second and therefore more collisions with the lattice every second.
- Doubling the current in a given cable raises the rate of heating in it by considerably more than double, which makes current the most powerful of the four levers.
- A cable feeding several appliances at once carries the sum of their currents, so plugging a fan heater and a kettle into the same lead can make that lead noticeably warm.
- Thin extension leads sold for lamps and radios are built for small currents only. Running a 13 A13\ \text{A}13 A appliance through such a lead forces far more charge through its thin wires each second than they were designed for, and the lead gets hot.
- Cables are therefore marked with a current rating in amperes, and that rating must be at least as large as the current the appliance draws through them.
- Two leads of the same thickness behave quite differently in use if one carries 0.50 A0.50\ \text{A}0.50 A to a phone charger and the other carries 10 A10\ \text{A}10 A to an electric heater. The heater lead needs the thicker copper.
Insulation and cable ratings
Definition
Electrical insulator
An electrical insulator is a material with almost no free charges, so it does not allow a current to flow through it.
- An electrical insulator has almost no free charges to move, so charge cannot flow through it. PVC, rubber and dry air are good insulators.
- A cable pairs the two kinds of material deliberately: a conductor core of copper to carry the charge with as little dissipation as possible, wrapped in an insulator of coloured plastic to keep that charge inside the cable.
- The insulation does nothing to reduce the heating. The energy is dissipated in the copper, and the plastic simply surrounds it and slows the escape of that energy to the air.
- Insulation is damaged by heat. A cable that runs too hot softens, then melts its plastic, after which the conductors inside can touch each other or be touched by a person.
- An undersized cable is therefore a fire risk. The energy dissipated in its thin conductors raises the temperature of the insulation and of anything packed around the cable.
- An undersized cable has a second and quieter drawback. A larger share of the supply potential difference is used up along the cable, so less is left across the appliance and the appliance runs below its intended output.
- A well-designed cable is a compromise between four demands: low dissipation, low cost, enough flexibility to be used, and enough length to reach.
Common Mistake
- Do not say a thicker wire has more resistance because there is more metal in it. A larger cross-sectional area gives the charge more room, so the resistance is lower.
- Do not write that copper has no resistance. Its resistance is small, not zero, and a long copper cable carrying a large current still gets warm.
- Do not answer with a vague improvement such as use a better wire. Name the change: a metal of lower resistance, a larger cross-sectional area, a shorter length, or a smaller current.
- Do not confuse the insulation with the conductor. The plastic sheath carries no current, so changing the sheath does not change the resistance of the cable.
- Do not suggest thicker insulation as a way of reducing the heating. Extra insulation traps the dissipated energy inside the cable and makes it hotter.
- Do not explain a long lead by saying the electrons get tired. The extra length means extra resistance, and so more energy dissipated in the lead itself.
Exam technique
Answering on cable design
- State the change and then its effect, for example use copper rather than iron, because copper has a lower resistance, so less energy is dissipated in the lead.
- Name the metal when a question asks which material to choose. Copper earns the mark where a general phrase such as a good conductor may not.
- Say larger cross-sectional area rather than bigger wire, since area is the quantity resistance depends on.
- Give genuinely different levers when two improvements are asked for. A shorter lead and a thicker lead count as two; thicker and wider count as one.
- Use directly proportional only where it is earned: resistance against length for a wire of fixed thickness qualifies, resistance against area does not.
- Finish an explanation at the energy, not at the resistance. Lower resistance is only worth marks once it is linked to less energy dissipated in the cable.
Self review
- List the four changes that reduce the energy dissipated in a connecting cable.
- Explain why a wire of larger cross-sectional area has a lower resistance.
- State why copper rather than iron is used for a mains cable.
- Explain why a thin extension lead becomes warm when a heater is plugged into it.
- Give two problems caused by fitting a cable that is too thin for the current it carries.