Two different things that can happen
Definition
Irradiation
Irradiation is the exposure of an object or a living organism to ionising radiation coming from a source outside it.
Definition
Radioactive contamination
Radioactive contamination is the unwanted presence of radioactive material on or inside an object or a living organism.
- The whole distinction rests on one question: has any radioactive material been moved onto or into the object?
- In irradiation the answer is no: alpha particles, beta particles or gamma rays travel across from the source, deposit energy and are absorbed, but the unstable nuclei stay where they were.
- In contamination the answer is yes: atoms with unstable nuclei end up on the skin, on a surface, or inside the body, and they carry on decaying there.
- An object can be irradiated without being contaminated, contaminated without anyone realising, or both at the same time.
The effects of irradiation
- While the radiation is arriving, it ionises molecules in whatever it passes through, so living cells can be killed and DNA can be altered.
- The moment the source is taken away, shielded or switched off, the exposure stops immediately.
- The irradiated object does not become radioactive, because nothing has been added to it that has an unstable nucleus.
- A patient who has had an X-ray, a syringe that has been sterilised and a strawberry that has been irradiated are all safe to handle straight afterwards for exactly this reason.
- The size of the hazard depends on the type of radiation, the activity of the source, the time spent near it, the distance from it and the shielding used, so all of those can be controlled.
- From outside the body, gamma radiation is the greatest irradiation hazard because it penetrates deeply, while alpha radiation is the least because the dead outer layer of skin absorbs it.
The effects of contamination
- Contamination happens when radioactive dust settles on skin or clothing, when a radioactive liquid is spilled, when radioactive gas is breathed in, or when radioactive material is swallowed with food or water or enters through a cut.
- Once the material is there, the object or person carries the source with them, so moving away from the original spill changes nothing.
- The exposure continues until the material is washed or cleaned away, is excreted by the body, or has decayed to a low activity, and none of those can be done instantly.
- Contamination also spreads, because contaminated hands touch door handles and contaminated boots walk material out of the laboratory.
- Contamination inside the body is the most serious case, because there is no layer of skin between the source and living cells.
- This reverses the usual ranking: an alpha emitter is the most dangerous contaminant, because it is strongly ionising and deposits all of its energy in a very small volume of living tissue.
- Some contaminants are worse still because the body concentrates them: radioactive iodine collects in the thyroid gland and strontium behaves chemically like calcium, so it is built into bone.
- Contamination is controlled by keeping sources sealed, working over trays, wearing gloves and laboratory coats, banning food and drink, and monitoring hands and surfaces with a detector before leaving.
Key Idea
- Irradiation transfers energy by radiation and ends when the source is removed.
- Contamination transfers radioactive material and continues until that material is removed or decays.
Comparing the hazards
- Both hazards do their damage the same way, by ionising molecules in cells, so the difference is not in the kind of harm but in how long it goes on and how easily it can be stopped.
- Duration: irradiation is over the instant the source is gone, whereas contamination keeps exposing the person for as long as the material stays put.
- Control: irradiation is reduced by time, distance and shielding, while contamination is dealt with by removing the material and by stopping it spreading.
- Reach: irradiation affects only what is within range of the source, while contamination travels wherever the contaminated person, object, air or water goes.
- Radiation type: gamma is the worst for irradiation from outside, and alpha is the worst for contamination inside the body.
- Neither is always the more dangerous, and the honest comparison depends on the numbers in the situation.
- A few minutes beside a high-activity gamma source can give a larger exposure than a trace of contamination ever would.
- Contamination of a large area with a long-lived isotope is the harder problem, because the exposure cannot be switched off and the land may stay unusable for decades.
Example
Sorting out a laboratory accident
- A technician spends ten minutes working a metre away from a sealed gamma source, and then knocks over a beaker of radioactive liquid, which soaks into her sleeve.
- The ten minutes beside the sealed source is irradiation, because gamma rays reach her but the radioactive material stays sealed inside its capsule.
- That exposure ended as soon as she stepped away, and she is not radioactive as a result of it.
- The spill is contamination, because unstable nuclei are now held in the fabric of her sleeve, a few centimetres from her arm.
- Those nuclei carry on decaying, so her arm keeps being exposed even after she leaves the laboratory, and anything she touches may become contaminated too.
- The correct action is to remove and bag the coat, wash the skin underneath, and check her hands and the bench with a detector before anyone leaves the room.
Exam technique
Comparing without losing marks
- Use the phrase radioactive material for contamination and the phrase exposed to radiation from an external source for irradiation, because those are the wordings the mark schemes credit.
- A compare question needs both processes described, so a paragraph about contamination alone cannot score the comparison marks however good it is.
- Add the consequence as well as the definition: say that the contaminated object continues to emit radiation, and that the irradiated object stops being exposed.
- If you are asked which is more dangerous, name the condition your answer depends on rather than picking one outright, for example that contamination is worse when the isotope is long-lived and gets inside the body.
- In a scenario question, label each event in the stem as one or the other before you start writing, since most of the marks come from getting that labelling right.
Common Mistake
- Do not use the two words as though they mean the same thing; contamination moves material and irradiation moves only energy.
- Do not write that an irradiated object becomes radioactive, however long it was left near the source.
- Do not say contamination is always more dangerous; a large exposure from a nearby source can do more harm in minutes.
- Do not carry the outside-the-body ranking inside it; alpha is the least hazardous from outside and the most hazardous once swallowed or inhaled.
- Do not suggest that shielding solves contamination; the material is already past the shielding and has to be removed.
Self review
- State what is transferred during contamination and what is transferred during irradiation.
- Explain why an irradiated object does not become radioactive.
- Explain why contamination can keep exposing someone after they have left the room.
- Explain why an alpha emitter is the most hazardous contaminant inside the body but the least hazardous source outside it.
- Give two precautions that reduce irradiation and two that reduce contamination.
- Describe a situation in which irradiation would be the greater hazard and one in which contamination would be.