Text 1: The hour rang out again, by Owen Price
An original contemporary newspaper feature.
During a test shortly before noon, the first chime sounded slightly flat. People in the square looked up anyway. A child clapped; an old man took off his cap. For the first time in eleven years, the clock on the east tower was working again.
The town had argued about the repair for months. Some wanted the money spent on the leaking roof of the market hall. Others said a stopped clock made the centre look abandoned. I went to the opening expecting a tidy ceremony and a few photographs. What I found was a crowd of people who had come carrying memories of the sound.
Mrs Evans, who runs the flower stall, said she used to set her watch by the clock as a girl. A bus driver told me he could hear it from the depot and would miss it on his days off. One man stood with his hands in his pockets and said nothing at all. When the minute hand began to move, he smiled at it as if it had recognised him.
The repair was not simple. Rain had got behind the face, and the wooden framework was soft in places. The clockmaker explained that each part had to be removed, cleaned and fitted back carefully. He spoke in the plain, patient manner of someone describing a long job to a person who has already asked how much it cost.
There was no ribbon to cut. The council chair thanked the volunteers, then stepped aside. At twelve, the bell rang again, this time on the hour. I noticed the market traders carry on weighing apples and folding paper, but several of them were smiling. The clock had not brought the town to a halt. It had simply given everyone the same moment to hear.
Text 2: The clock is to be heard once more, by Thomas Bell
An original letter written in a nineteenth-century voice; a period simulation, not an archival document.
In this letter, written in 1894, a baker writes to his brother about the restoration of the town clock.
Dear Edward, the clock was set in motion again yesterday, after a silence so long that some of the younger children had never heard it. The council arranged for the mayor to turn the key before a gathering in the square. He did so with great care, and the crowd waited as though a proclamation were to be made.
The first stroke came out thin and uncertain. A few people laughed, but nobody went away. The clockmaker, who had been standing near the tower door, looked up with a frown and then nodded. The next stroke was clearer. I confess that I had expected a more impressive sound, yet I found myself listening for the next one.
My shop is close enough that the old clock once marked the hours of my work. When it stopped, I learned to look at the sun or ask a customer the time. I did not think I missed the bell until it returned. Yesterday I stood in the doorway with flour on my sleeve and remembered my father closing the shutters at the last chime.
Not everyone is pleased. The grocer says the repair cost too much when several streets still need paving. I understand his complaint, but the tower has stood above the square for longer than any of us, and it seemed wrong to leave it silent. The mayor spoke of civic pride, though the people appeared more moved by the sound than by his words.
In the evening, I heard the clock from my kitchen. Its tone was still rough, but it was there. I cannot say it will make the town richer or happier. I only know that, for a moment, the familiar hour had returned. Your brother, Thomas.
Compare what the writers say about the clock’s return and how they present their thoughts and feelings about this event. You must use the text to support your comments and make it clear which text you are referring to.
110 exam-style questions on Eduqas GCSE English Language 2.4 Comparing texts, covering 2.4.1 Critical comparison of two or more texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.