Governments pursue other objectives beyond growth, jobs and prices
- Alongside the four principal objectives, growth, price stability, full employment and a stable balance of payments, governments hold other objectives too.
- These include reducing inequality and managing environmental change, reflecting a wish for an economy that is fair and sustainable, not just large.
Reducing inequality is another government objective
- An unequal distribution of income or wealth across the population, covered fully in 2.2.6, means fewer people live in poverty when that gap between richest and poorest households is smaller.
- Government policy can narrow this gap through progressive taxation and through benefits and public services targeted at lower-income households, covered in more depth elsewhere.
- The UK's Gini coefficient for disposable income was 32.9 per cent in the year to March 2024, a standard measure of how unequally income is spread.
- In the same year, the richest fifth of households had around 5.6 times the disposable income of the poorest fifth.
- Median household disposable income was £36,700 a year in the same period.
Managing environmental change is another objective
Sustainable development: meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.
- Using resources today should not leave future generations worse off, so development is only sustainable if it can continue over the long term.
- A country that plants new trees to replace the ones it cuts down can keep using timber for years to come.
- A country that clears its forests without replanting gains wood now but leaves nothing for the future.
Growth can deplete resources and damage the environment
- Depleting resources: using non-renewable resources such as oil, coal and metals means less is left for future generations.
- Pollution: more production and transport can raise air and water pollution, which harms health and the natural world.
- Environmental damage: overfishing and burning fossil fuels can cause lasting harm such as deforestation and climate change.
Sustainable development does not mean stopping growth. It means making growth cleaner and longer lasting, so resources and the environment are not used up faster than they can recover.
Countries can take steps to make growth more sustainable
- Countries can make growth more sustainable by switching to renewable energy such as wind and solar, conserving resources through recycling, and controlling pollution with rules and taxes.
- These steps can cost more or slow growth in the short term, so governments must weigh the benefits to the future against the costs today.
Moral and ethical considerations underpin these objectives
Ethical considerations: ideas about what is right and fair that guide the choices a government makes.
- These include a duty to look after the poorest people in society and a duty to protect the planet for future generations.
- For many governments, reducing inequality and protecting the environment are valued as objectives in their own right, not only because they support growth.
Pursuing one objective can harm a specific group
- A policy aimed at one objective can help the country overall while still making a particular group of people worse off.
- Raising interest rates to fight inflation: raises monthly repayments for people with a variable-rate or newly fixed mortgage, even though it helps savers and slows inflation for everyone.
- Taxing carbon-heavy industries to protect the environment: can raise costs and put jobs at risk in specific industries, such as steel or oil and gas, even though it benefits the wider population through a cleaner environment.
- Raising the minimum wage to reduce in-work poverty: raises pay for low-paid workers who keep their jobs, but can make some low-skilled jobs too expensive for firms to keep, risking job losses for a smaller group.
Judgement: a policy that harms a specific group is not automatically wrong, since it can still be worth it if it raises wellbeing overall, but who bears the cost is still part of judging how fair or acceptable the policy is.
Weighing costs to one group against wider gains
- This weighing up applies to each example above, from mortgage holders facing higher repayments to workers in carbon-heavy industries and low-skilled workers priced out of jobs, since each is a specific group bearing a cost while the wider population gains.
Name the specific group harmed by a policy, not just that it has downsides, then weigh the size of that harm against the wider benefit.
- Name two government objectives other than growth, price stability, full employment and the balance of payments.
- Define sustainable development.
- Give two ways economic growth can harm the environment.
- What are ethical considerations, and how do they shape government objectives?
- Give one example of a policy that helps the economy overall but harms a specific group of people.